Celestino's NY Pizza & Pasta — Restaurant in Rocklin

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Celestino's NY Pizza & Pasta in Rocklin, CA, and I must say, it was an absolute delight! From the convenient location with ample parking spaces to the mouthwatering eggplant parmesan and the friendly staff, Celestino's truly delivers an authentic taste of New York.

First and foremost, the convenience of this Celestino's location is a definite plus. With parking being a challenge in many places, it's refreshing to find a restaurant that offers plenty of parking spaces. Whether you're visiting for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, you can easily find a spot without any hassle.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the eggplant parmesan. As an avid fan of Italian cuisine, I have tasted my fair share of eggplant parmesan, and Celestino's version is nothing short of exceptional. The dish was a delightful blend of flavors and textures, with perfectly cooked and tender eggplant slices, a rich tomato sauce, and a generous layer of melted cheese. Each bite was a heavenly combination of savory goodness, leaving me longing for more. If you're a fan of eggplant parmesan or simply appreciate delicious Italian fare, Celestino's will not disappoint.

Beyond the delectable food, the staff at Celestino's truly shine. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warm smiles and a genuine desire to make my dining experience memorable. The staff members were not only friendly but also attentive and accommodating. They were more than happy to provide recommendations, answer any questions I had, and ensure that every aspect of my visit was enjoyable. The exceptional service added a personal touch that made me feel welcome and valued as a customer.

In addition to the fantastic food and friendly staff, the atmosphere at Celestino's is cozy and inviting. The restaurant has a classic New York pizzeria ambiance, with its charming decor and comfortable seating. Whether you choose to dine in or take your food to go, you can expect a welcoming environment that enhances the overall dining experience.

To sum it up, Celestino's NY Pizza & Pasta in Rocklin, CA, is a true gem for anyone seeking an authentic taste of New York. The convenient location with ample parking spaces, the mouthwatering eggplant parmesan, and the genuinely friendly staff all contribute to a memorable dining experience. Whether you're a pizza lover, a pasta enthusiast, or simply someone who appreciates delicious food and excellent service, Celestino's is a must-visit destination. Treat yourself to a slice of New York right here in Rocklin—you won't be...

06/14/25 Update: Went in for lunch and snatched up a slice of John Rambo (red sauce, Pepperoni, mushroom, olives) which was tasty and decided to go with a new one the 'Louie De Palma" (pepperoni, ricotta topping, garlic) which I guess was previously called the "Danny Devito". The flavors on both slices were absolutely fantastic and the staff very friendly.

Tip: if you are not ordering pizza by the slice, and are ordering a whole pizza, have them go longer on the crust. That way it will have more of the crunch that ordering by the slice has. You can thank me later.

04/16/25 Update: whatever was off on my previous visit was not an issue today. The Tom Jones pizza was on point...great crust, great flavors, friendly staff. The addictive elements are back! Maybe I did have a head cold on my previous review because today's pizza was delicious 🤤.

Update: Changed rating from four stars to three. I ordered the same thing as my previous review - great crunch, evenly spread out toppings. Sadly the other reviewer was correct - they changed their crust recipe and possibly the marinara sauce. It's like having pizza with a head cold. The addictive element is gone. Not sure why you'd mess with a recipe 25+ years old?

Previous Review: They started up in Chico and lucky for us they brought it down here to feed your face. Great pizza by the slice - crunchy crust and tasty toppings. If they have the "Godfather" out for pizza by the slice - grab one! The "Tom Jones" and the "White" pizzas are my usual choice.

The meatball sandwich is also something to give a go. The menu has something for pretty much everyone...salads,...

Not impressed with the service of this pizza place. Ordered ahead of time for pickup. Got inside and there were 7 customers hanging around. I asked a couple of people if they had ordered ahead of time or were just waiting to order. A couple had just ordered and were waiting and others were waiting for their pick up order too. Despite having 7 people running behind the counter, not a single person was on the register helping customers with their orders or pickup.

There’s no pick up sign or any direction of where the line should be. A couple of people that came in after me did the same thing and were just as confused of where they needed to go for their pick up order.

While I was waiting, I saw my pizza on the top of the shelf where they were putting all the pizzas they made. I asked one of the employees (bald headed white dude) if he could grab it and he said, “You got to wait in line!” and pointed towards the people that were waiting. Apparently, he was in a pissy mood. He could’ve just grabbed it for me but I had to wait another 10 minutes just to get my pizza.

The quality of the pizza is just okay and it’s really not that special. There’s a bunch of other pizza places around the area that offer much better quality, taste, and service.

I’d put this pizza slightly above Costco pizza but for...