Dutch Valley Restaurant
Dutch Valley Restaurant things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
I was told to make sure I stopped here while in Amish Country. This restaurant didn't disappoint! I couldn't decide what I wanted from the menu so I opted for the buffet. Great choice as a newbie here. I really got a feel for what my favorites are here now! If you're into fried chicken, the broasted chicken is excellent. Juicy and crispy, amazing really! The ham, meaty in texture cooked to perfection. The roast beef is tender. Some sides I liked better than others but still worthy of seconds. I wish they had an option with fish. Please don't skip the salad bar. There's much more than just greenery over there. Chicken Salad, yum! Pasta salad was unique, sweet and delicious. Here's a pro tip... if you get a salad, you must get croutons! These alone are worth the drive from anywhere in Ohio. What a pleasant garlic buttery surprise! Homemade applesauce and more. Save room for the pie. $1 off a slice if you get the buffet. There are limited desserts on the buffet if you don't have room for pie. All in all, yes you should eat here! #TiaTriedIt
Tia Tried ItTia Tried It
00
This place is amazing! The buffet food is phenomenal. It is the best buffet food I've ever had. The Amish can really cook! The table comes with bread and condiments such as Apple butter and peanut butter. The buffet comes with the salad bar. At the salad bar they put out random desserts and sometimes have cookies! Let me tell you, the Amish have perfected the chocolate chip cookie. My favorite buffet items are the pan seared chicken, sweet corn, and bread pudding. (Besides the cookies) I almost forgot about their broccoli cheese soup. It's the best broccoli cheese soup I've ever tasted. This place also has a lot of variety of pies and even had a pie day for March 14! They also have a bakery right next door and a gift shop too. If you are in the area, this is the place to go! Update 4 12 19: Added pics from Bakery. Update 11 20 2019: Amber was a wonder server! This place is still amazing as ever!
Climbing KittenClimbing Kitten
00
Dutch Valley has been our place that we have enjoyed years of large family gatherings. In October of 2024, my sister had a farewell dinner as she moved from Ohio to South Carolina. She left (literally in the U-Haul) from Dutch Valley to her new location. Dutch Valley did such a wonderful job allowing us to enjoy each others company and laugh and reminisce. Yesterday, we lost our grandmother and so this was truly our last big group gathering. We were able to take videos and pictures. Attached is the photo of the big lot of us in front of the U-Haul wishing my sister goodbye. Today I took my Dad there for his birthday (today) and sat at the same table our grandmother was at in that last big gathering in October. It’s a special place to our family. Service is excellent and the food is phenomenal. Don’t miss a visit here.
Clarissa McMorrowClarissa McMorrow
00
Overall, it was a good experience. Tge staff were friendly, but the waiter constantly walked past us and didn't ask us if we needed a refill even after I put my glass to the side...needless to say I had to wave her down 5 times everytime I wanted a drink. The overall environment was classier and much more upscale than I expected, but the restaurant still managed to keep that cute amish charm. Most of the food was good, besides the cream corn, which was shockingly bland, and the ham, which had a good flavor but had extremely tough skin and was overcooked overall. The broiled chicken, dressing, and bread pudding was definitely the best off of their dinner bar. Overall, I'd eat here again, just not so close to the kitchen where the waitresses seem to ignore people.
Amanda LeachAmanda Leach
00
Came here on our road trip with the in laws. We didn't have to wait at all to get a table. I got the buffet and it did not disappoint. All my favorites and really enjoyed it. The chocolate cake was spectacular. Roast had great flavor, mashed potatoes, and brown gravy was awesome. Kids vanilla ice cream with caramel was enough to share with the whole table. We are definitely going to try and make it back. Well worth it.
bryan roothbryan rooth
00
Got the buffet. Had a good time with the family. Very traditional food that was fresh. Would recommend.
Joshua OgurchakJoshua Ogurchak
00
Nearby Attractions Of Dutch Valley Restaurant
Ohio Star Theater at Dutch Valley
Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek
Sugar Valley Meats
Dutch Valley Campus
Dutch Valley Gifts
Dutch Valley Market
The Harvest Barn

Ohio Star Theater at Dutch Valley
4.7
(493)Click for details

Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek
4.8
(473)Click for details

Sugar Valley Meats
4.8
(133)Click for details

Dutch Valley Campus
4.6
(122)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
1343 Old Rte 39 NE, Sugarcreek, OH 44681
Map
Phone
(330) 852-4627
Call
Website
dutch-valley.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.6
(3.1K reviews)
Ratings & Description
Description
Relaxed, farmland pick for old-fashioned American meals served à la carte or all-you-can-eat.
attractions: Ohio Star Theater at Dutch Valley, Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek, Sugar Valley Meats, Dutch Valley Campus, Dutch Valley Gifts, Dutch Valley Market, The Harvest Barn, restaurants:

- Please manually select your location for better experience