More Than Pudding — Restaurant in Tallahassee

More than putting is a really nice store with frozen pudding that is amazingly unique in that it's not like gelato or is it like frozen yogurt it is a lot more creamier it is a must-have for a birthday party for somebody with a refined pallet. The owner is doing really good with her attitude in a time that's very slow and tallahassee. I went in there and it won't help me spoke to me about how they make what they make and the ins and outs of the coffee and the Frozen concoctions . It was amazingly refreshing (no pun intended) as the conversation was uplifting in the owner made me feel right at home even though I was only asking about her about the Lucky Goat Coffee that she sells. I wasn't buying anything and she knew that, yet, she made me feel right at home. I would recommend more than pudding to my friends, my family, complete strangers, and anybody that was seeking dessert a sweet had a sweet tooth, or just wanted some pudding, albeit Frozen. LOL. You can sample the plethora of frozen pudding flavors. I tried Banana Cream Pie Frozen Pudding. I swore I heard my Gram who passed ten years ago whisper to me..." It is not as good as Grannies is it?" I would have to hold my tounge and not tell her the truth. Her frozen banana cream pie pudding is to die for. It's cold food season folks ....get out this June and go get some stuff from "More Than Pudding" on the corner of Pennsicola and Appleyard drive. It is right next door to Moe's. ✓ it out. Bring your friends, family and everyone else to come support this beautiful...

1.3.2025 10 over 10 easily! I initially heard of this place via FB at least a month before trying. I spent about $50+ and I'll say it was worth all of it. I'm slowly & very rarely re-introducing my GI system to dairy; so, this menu may have been a little heavy on my gut (note that if you are on a reduced dairy diet). However..... I got 3 different bread pudding flavors (can't remember which) and a small cup of butter pecan custard. The custards gave soft serve ice cream; without the guilt though. All were obviously handcrafted, fresh, and rich with flavor. I called ahead w/ questions and the counter person was just as patient and courteous on the phone as in person. Regretfully, (maybe not so much 😆) I live too far to visit more often.... Congrats on a winning biz concept, as well!

Shop small...

I rarely ever leave reviews but I just had to for this place. I ordered on doordash. I have been wanting to try this place since it opened. I love custard pudding and bread pudding so much so having a place with both is a dream come true. The bread pudding was the best I’ve ever had. It was warm and so yummy. I got the cookie butter flavor. The pudding was perfect. I can never find bananas foster anything so I had to get that flavor as it’s one of my favorites. It was so good!! It was better than expected. A lot of puddings to me can taste artificial especially when it comes to banana but you could tell it was fresh and didn’t have that taste at all. I also like that you can get a “kiddie” portion and it’s more than enough. I can’t wait to try more...