John & Mary's Millersport — Restaurant in Town of Amherst

Girl making the sandwiches was very impolite and grumpy. Curly fries were cheap and undercooked and the chicken fingers were horrible and tasteless with hard chunks of fat. Never again.

In reply to the owners comment: After reading comments to other customers reviews I can see where the issue lies.On my visit there were two employees working at the time and only myself and 1 other customer in the restaurant. Working long hours and being short staffed should never be an excuse for poor/rude customer service. Maybe keep in mind the old saying...without our customers, we wouldn't be here. Another thought could be that if you're going to reply to any customers review maybe atleast try to come off in a polite manner and not the way you did to me and others. Maybe this is part of the issue and where it stems from. Always...

If you're heading down Millersport Highway and you see this place, just keep driving.

I gave this place a try, and was put off at first by the overall scumminess of the restaurant, and was struck by the lack of any of the amenities a restaurant typically has, like flatware, napkin dispensers, and so on.

I ordered two slices of pizza to eat in the restaurant, and even though the receipt clearly read, "FOR HERE," the cook decided that I wanted it "TO GO."

I opened the box with the two slices in it and realized these were two thoroughly uncooked slices of pizza.

Rather than trust this crew to take the slices back and cook them properly, I tossed the disgusting slices in the trash on the way out the door and headed over to the nearby Burger King.

Definitely learned my lesson, I won't be setting foot in that...

My son and I came in for dinner. The staff that took the order was great. The chicken parm subs we ordered were not very hot at all, plus the cheese was slapped on half on the sandwich half out and was hoping it would be real stringy when you bit into not the case. The old lady that was working with three young teenagers was not very polite to one of them. She asked the young girl why do you think you do this setting up a tray and the girl gave her an answer and said to her you need to shut up and let me speak at this moment. My son and I could not believe the way the older lady spoke to the young teen. We will not be back to this place ever again. Very rude way to talk to your young employees you have working for you. Also the subs were not hot at all. We have gone to other places and get...