Cicero's — Restaurant in Town of Clarkstown

Been ordering from here for years. The last two orders have been a nightmare. Last month the pizza came 20min late and the cheese and pepperoni on the pie shifted to one side of the box. Not normally a problem but I had to wait for them to come back with a new pie. Tonight I ordered 4 pies they told my wife 35-40 min. They didn’t show up for an hour and a half later. We stared calling an hour in, no answers. Finally when we got through at the hour and a half mark, the kid answering the phone told me they left them at the door because nobody was there. I have 5 kids plus my wife and I that’s 7 people and nobody heard a knock. Nor did we receive a phone call. All 4 pizzas was ice cold and when I told the kid on the phone he hung the phone up on me without saying a word. I have a long history ordering from them sometimes up to 3x a week, this is the last time. There are many pizza joints in town, my advice order from another spot. I don’t know what happened to this pace but they just don’t...

Past four weeks they don’t have enough food during lunchtime. Never seen this before anywhere-isn’t that their bread and butter to sell food and have enough??!! You place an order , you go to pick it up and then they tell you they don’t have the food you ordered. They don’t give you the courtesy to call you back to tell you sorry we have to make a pie for your individual slices due to we’re out and it will be a longer wait to pick up. But a common sense worker would look while your on the phone to see if they have the slices made to order and if they don’t it will be a longer wait. We been going to this place way over 20 years every Friday and they’ve lost my business and I’m gonna make sure everybody I know doesn’t go there anymore. If they don’t care about the customers then they don’t deserve business or they should hire new...

After hearing about the place we were in the area and decided to give it a try. We started off with the tzatziki spread. It was thick and had very little flavor. If I had to guess they opened up a Greek yogurt, sprinkled some dill and garlic oil on it and mixed it around. There was no flavor of cucumber, dill or garlic or lemon. You know what changes Greek Yogurt to Tzatziki. My wife had a gyro but instead of lamb they used pork. Strange. i had pastitsio which look good but it was tasteless until I added both pepper and salt. It was not like I just added a pinch. It seemed that whom ever make it, forgot to use any seasoning. I was surprised considering that the place was busy. I enjoy good Greek food and this was a poor...