Inlet Seafood Restaurant
Inlet Seafood Restaurant things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Description
Owned by commercial fishermen, this 2-story American seafood eatery also offers sushi & inlet views.
attractions: Montauk Yacht Club, Montauk County Park, Sun 'N' Sound, The Sunset Montauk, Sunset Beach, Gin Beach, restaurants: Gosman's Restaurant, Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock, The Dock Bar & Grill, Sammys, Seaside House Bar, Kenny's Castaways, Gin Beach Cafe, Goldberg's, Star Island Grill, Rooted
Ratings
Description
Owned by commercial fishermen, this 2-story American seafood eatery also offers sushi & inlet views.
Posts
7-Day Diary of Eating, Drinking, and Exploring from Europe to New York
HannahHannah
50
Food was good. Service was a bit lacking but they seemed understaffed and probably didn’t care to put too much effort considering we were a party of 6 and gratuity was guaranteed. Disappointed they were unable to honor the kids eat free advertisement from a recent and local paper. Was told that ended Memorial Day weekend but clearly nothing in the ad states that. False advertising to me. When we spoke to the Manager working that night, she refused to take any accountability and stated it was her boss’ decision and that I should have confirmed upon arrival. Kudos to her for standing up for what seems like a sleazy marketing scheme. Was told “it’s only $12” but for 3 kids…$36 for $5 in pasta? I get it, mark up, inflation blah blah blah but as a Manager, some empathy can go a long way. Wouldn’t it have been easier and maybe a better business outcome if you just honored the deal? As a still very new parent of two young kids, I was very surprised and pleased to see there still exists an establishment that offers a kids deal like that. You don’t see that often and had that been honored, the overall experience would have five star. Looking forward to management’s response, probably will make accusations of my behavior, which I’ll admit, I got frustrated - but only because some of the commentary from the Manager was rather shocking. Not sure what I did to deserve it, maybe it was my appearance, not enough beige. Shame. Really, just all a shame. Oh yeah, that old fashioned was anything but a proper cocktail. I’m not some bourbon snob but when there’s that much ice in a whiskey drink, it’s usually a good tell of what kind of place you’re at.
John BabuJohn Babu
10
Such a great location, sunsets and storms must be amazing from this spot. I had the shrimp bisque, it was delicious. It had a lovely complex bisque flavor, not overly strong or overly thick. I ordered the soft shell crab sandwich, I should have read it more closely The batter was a bit heavy, taking away from the delicate crab. The batter was also not very flavorful. The slaw on the sandwich of julienned veggies and a vinegar dressing was delicious. My sandwich was served with fries, a smaller than normal portion. Cole slaw was also included, maybe it’s me but Cole slaw should be served cold. My partner ordered the grilled octopus appetizer. At $22 for this appetizer, I was dismayed to see a very small amount of octopus. The salad, bread and beans that accompanied it were delicious. The decaf coffee I ordered tasted old, too off taste to drink. I would go back because of the location, I think I would order my seafood less dressed.
Rosanne MalusaRosanne Malusa
20
DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME WITH THIS RESTAURANT. We decided to come on Labor Day weekend for dinner. We waited over an hour for a table... which is fine, I expected this on a such busy holiday weekend on a gorgeous day. What I didn't expect is that so many people were waiting for a dinner at place where the food was awful. We started with the tuna tataki and grilled artichoke. The tuna was just gross with an awful flavor and the grilled artichoke was a... grilled artichoke. I had the fluke picatta that had no flavor and the breading was very soggy. My husband had the stuffed lobster and I'm not sure what it was stuffed with but it looked like mushy baby food. I truly would have rather enjoyed a meal of saltines. The view and setting of the location are very nice. The service was fine. I would never go back or ever recommend the restaurant to even an enemy (well, maybe an enemy).
David HabeggerDavid Habegger
20
Absolutely stunning location and kind, friendly service. There's outdoor seating as well as indoor seating with amazing views of the water. We came here starving from our long drive from NJ and we're eagerly anticipating our meal based on prior reviews. Overall, the food was mediocre. Unfortunately, the mussels with marinara sauce had a stale and rotten smell and taste. After 2 bites we knew it was not fresh. The pasta and tilefish special were not seasoned at all. They both required a lot of extra salt and seasoning at the table. The fried shrimp sandwich was heavily breaded with a large amount of cheese and bacon that detracted the taste of shrimp. The soft shell crab sandwich was ok... the crab was small and also heavily breaded. I would come back for the views and a drink but not for the food.
Angela KimAngela Kim
10
I love this place. The view and the food is worth the trip from the city to Montauk 3-4 hrs drive. Anything seafood is delicious - complements to the chef.
Nie ZnanyNie Znany
00
Nearby Attractions Of Inlet Seafood Restaurant
Montauk Yacht Club
Montauk County Park
Sun 'N' Sound
The Sunset Montauk
Sunset Beach
Gin Beach

Montauk Yacht Club
4.2
(231)Click for details

Montauk County Park
4.8
(71)Click for details

Sun 'N' Sound
4.4
(53)Click for details

The Sunset Montauk
4.7
(46)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Inlet Seafood Restaurant
Gosman's Restaurant
Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock
The Dock Bar & Grill
Sammys
Seaside House Bar
Kenny's Castaways
Gin Beach Cafe
Goldberg's
Star Island Grill
Rooted

Gosman's Restaurant
4.1
(754)$$
Click for details

Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock
4.1
(223)$$
Click for details

The Dock Bar & Grill
4.5
(196)Click for details

Sammys
4.1
(127)$
Click for details
Reviews
- Unable to get your location