Captain Lawrence Brewing Company — Restaurant in Town of Greenburgh

Talk about busy! This appears to be the happening spot on a Sat night. One thing that's pretty cool is that they allow kids in here. Not sure if there's a cut off time when it becomes adults only but I'm sure there is. Anyways, pizza. When it comes to food that's what they appear to be about and I'd have to say they do it well. We got the sausage pizza, one size only, price is decent for what you get. It's a good pizza and more filling than I though when I first saw it. We also got the kids chicken fingers for the nephew. I will say that their kids serving was quite large. We pay much all ended up eating from it. Next, the beer. I'm down with this places beer. I only got one pint and it was the Autumn Blaze. I thoroughly enjoyed this beer. I'm a sucker for pumpkin beers and though this was one of the most didn't pumpkin flavors in a pumpkin beer I've had, and I mean subtle, it was a well rounded beer. I honestly wanted a second it to definitely taste what else they had to offer but just didn't have the time. I saw a super hazy on the list and was torn between the two b/c I love me a hazy as well. Seating in this place is aight. It's seat yourself. There's hella picnic table style seating like Oktoberfest but when you start getting more and more larger ppl in there the ability to get around diminishes pretty quickly. It is loud in there and I do mean loud. At times it was difficult to hold a conversion across the table. They have hella tv's. Gotta order everything at the bar and pickup your food yourself which is when that comment about it being difficult to maneuver comes in play. But everyone was nice and would move when you yelled "excuse me!" There appeared to be a whole other section for searing that seemed like it would of been a a lot quieter but it was taken up by a private party so we sat in the zoo. Service is quick. Our food was ready within minutes of ordering. They are fast and efficient. Definitely want to come back to try more of their...

I’ve been to Captain Lawrence a few times now and it’s consistently good. We first started coming here during the pandemic trying to help out small businesses and ordering from their takeout menu. Since then we’ve been back several times for warm sunny days outside, cold days inside, Oktoberfest in the back room, and more. Each time has been pretty good but always has something missing! A few times we’ve had issues with servers being unfriendly or unresponsive, a few times I haven’t loved my food but this time was probably the best! Our server was pretty friendly, it wasn’t too crowded (and wow does it get crowded!). We came at like 4 on a Friday (I wish they had some happy hour specials!) and they already had spaces reserved for 6 that we couldn’t sit at. I thought it was a bit early but by 5 the place was getting quite packed. We ordered the pizza and fries to eat. I got the pizza with no Moz as usual (can’t eat it) and asked for a little extra sauce on that side since it sometimes gets a little dry with no cheese. They didn’t do that for me which was unfortunate, but it still tasted fine. The fries were nice and crispy but they were wayyy too salty for me. I ordered the vodka pink lemonade (in a can) and it was delicious. My bf got 2 beers and said they were both good! Overall, this place is good and...

I’ve always enjoyed the vibe and atmosphere here, the service is usually fine.

Unfortunately, our experience was ruined by how the kitchen handled a really simple (but important) issue, especially since it involved food for my daughter.

We ordered the kids chicken fingers- when I cut them up for her I noticed they arrived icy cold in the center—clearly undercooked and straight from frozen. That’s not just unappetizing, it’s potentially unsafe- especially for a child. I politely sent them back, assuming we’d receive a freshly cooked batch.

What came out next was strange and frustrating- the chicken fingers had been cut in half before frying, which made them incredibly oily and inedible. It felt like the kitchen either rushed the fix or decided to make a point instead of just correcting the issue the right way. No explanation, no apology—just gross food, twice in a row.

The server was great, but I don’t know if it was incompetence or a passive aggressive move by the kitchen staff which should’ve been easily solved with a thermometer. When you’re serving families—especially children—basic food safety and professionalism should be the bare minimum.

Also- half their menu was unavailable until 2pm, they should probably put that on their menu / website so people know you can’t order pizza...