Bayport Deli & Convenience — Restaurant in Town of Islip

EDIT: If you would like to talk about being treating poorly, maybe we can refer back to how two of the employees, one woman and one man, chased after us and recorded us. Are you children? Do we leave our place of work to record 16 year olds? Not sure. I’m not sure who Sandy is, but the owner of this establishment did yell at the receptionist, which makes no sense, because the parking lot is to be shared. If there are more parking lot spaces taken up by the rescue, that is not something we can control. Maybe a kinder conversation would’ve gotten farther, as you’re yelling when the spots do not legally belong to your establishment. The problem is, the rudeness you display, even taking it far enough to leave your work, take out your phones, and RECORD either the cars or two 16 year olds (us). It showcases the kind of way you’d treat your costumers.

I used to go to this deli after volunteering at the rescue nearby. I would always order food and drinks from here and never had a problem until they yelled at the receptionist at the rescue stating that we were taking up their parking spots when they put up signs saying that we can’t park there and always follow their “rules” to avoid conflict. They yelled at the poor lady and the following volunteers when it’s a public parking lot and most, if not all, the volunteers park right on the left side of the rescue. I have also had my own encounter where I was treated poorly due to the fact that I forgot about the debit minimum of $10. They are unreasonably rude and yell at the volunteers just for walking the dogs on the sidewalk?? I wish the rescue would be more supported by...

Owners have "issues", nasty, scream, chase customers away. Blames lack of business on "dog walkers" despite dogs being walked on PUBLIC SIDEWALK. Has SIGNS saying "Deli Parking Only" on spaces that are EMPTY ALL DAY. Stand looking out window, waiting to fly out front door & yell. At old people, kids, families. Carol's has bent over backwards, put up signs, instructed Staff, etc., AVOID the Deli area. NOTHING pleases this crazy woman. NOTHING. The PIZZERIA on opposite corner LOVES dogs. THEIR Customers park in the SHARED LOT. Carol's does NOT CHASE CUSTOMERS of ANY BUSINESS from a Parking Spot. ALL Customers DESERVE respectful treatment. SO MANY of "the dog walkers" (volunteers from community) stated they USED to go to that Deli. NEVER AGAIN. I used to go there. Back wall by Grill is DARK, GREASY. A huge ICEBERG in their freezer means it was never sanitized. A slow Deli is NOT the place to order "fresh" food. Package, bottle, OK. To make matters worse, this Deli is asking FRIENDS to leave FALSE BAD REVIEWS for a Non Profit Business, Carol's, which has brought HUNDREDS of TikTok Followers to the Bayport area, including the Pizzeria, which is BUSIER THAN EVER thanks to the...

This deli is truly a gem! You can immediately feel that it’s a family-owned business because of the warm and welcoming atmosphere the staff creates the moment you walk in. The workers treat you like family, always friendly and attentive, which makes every visit a pleasure. The quality of the food matches the kindness of the service—fresh, delicious, and made with care. A beautiful spot that’s become my go-to, not just for the great food but for the genuine people behind it....