Noto's Italian Deli & Catering — Restaurant in Town of Newburgh

Extremely disappointed! About a year ago I got a super antipasto platter to bring to a party. It was delicious and I thought I would buy another just for us to enjoy at home. I saw that the price went up by $20, but what hasn't? The platter shrunk! The prosciutto was sliced very thick. The cherry peppers were stuffed with a soft cheese that fell apart almost to powder with a sharp bite of vinegar. the roasted red peppers were more garlic than pepper, as were the mozzarella pearls. What was a sharp hard provolone or pecorino last year was a soft provolone today. There were no pepperoncini's. the button mushrooms, olives and pepperoni we all good, but they were prepackaged products. I am not one to complain but I am glad I didn't buy this platter to share with friends and family. The last one was the hit...

I ordered the route 52 and it was hands down the worst sandwich I have ever got in my life. Bread was soggy to the point of falling apart, and it’s supposed to be a panini, so it should be crispy have no idea how they messed that up so bad. The description says “diced” chicken breast, instead it came with sliced deli bought chicken. The description also says portabello mushrooms and I can promise you that these are not portabellos. So not only did they lie on their website, they couldn’t even lie and make a somewhat edible sandwich. It was honestly disgusting and I threw it out after like two bites. Going to tell all my co-workers to stay far away....

It's so hard to find a good deli these days and this place truly lives up to its reputation! My wife started bringing sandwiches home from here after our old go-to shut down and now it's our #1 spot.

Lately we've been obsessed with the Papa Joe sub (cappy ham, prosciutto, pepperoni, soppresatta, provolone, hot peppers, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, and vinegar). Absolute beast of a sandwich, and ordering a whole one fills me up for lunch and dinner.

Another plus is the mac salad, which I judge every good deli by. It's homemade and very close in taste to my grandfather's deli from the Bronx...