Angelina's — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

On indefinite replay!!! Been going for years and not lost its touch, spark, and high caliber. For what it is, and what it offers its a quiet low-key spot. Love the location and popping by for a casual meal. Fabulously prepared meals for exquisite tastes are offered at this warm and cozy restaurant. Would recommend to anyone looking for an outstanding culinary experience; Had remarkable and unforgettable personal moments in time right there, which makes the place even more special for me. Menu is impeccably curated; you can't go wrong ordering. Wine and cocktails are lovely; ask for pairing suggestions, it has helped me discover new wines instead of always ordering the same. Perfect spot for dates, friends, celebrations... or simply a low-key weeknight meal. This will be the best meal you will ever have, and it is worth every penny. Everything is delicious. The pasta dishes are particularly impressive. The service is outstanding. Everyone is extremely knowledgeable and enthusiastic, especially...

A significant step above the typical, good ol' Long Island red-sauce slinger, and yet somehow lower priced than anything Il Mulino-ish -is Angelina's.

I truly fear publishing how incredible their Chicken Scarp is, because it's one of the best, most well balanced, and healthy-ish plates of food ever served on the planet. Ask those in the know, Big Tony, Short Schmuel, and even me, Frankly-The-Foody, Angelina's hits on every level. Stand outs include baked clams- they consistently use the smaller, sweeter clams served whole that offer a more satisfying petite amuse bouch that doesn't require the chewiness of the typical baked clams. Also, Chicken Giamundo is just another name for the best Chicken Marsala you've ever had. And just to prove their Southern Italian resumé, one would be forgiven for dreaming of swimming in their fra'diavola sauce (although it will definitely burn a bit).

Only facia bruta's wouldn't be floored by the quality of...

Lovely, cozy restaurant with an interesting menu and great service! Everything here is great. My favorite is the chicken livers appetizer! There are delicious daily specials that aren't on the website. One of my favorite places for Italian! I'm eating leftovers right now lol... fettuccine with sausage, shrimp, calamari, spinach, red tomatoes in garlic & olive oil. Yum! I go here regularly!

Update a year later: The soft shell crab & monkfish special was so good! As well as my fave: the livers, as usual. Such a great staff...