Crostini Pizza North Broadway — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

My most recent experience with Crostini’s pizza was of the utmost excellence I have experienced in a long time. Joe, the owner, had displayed such loyalty to a stranger he had never spoken to in his life for a $14.39 situation I had called him about regarding a UberEats cancellation that was charged to my account and I had paid his driver in cash. His diligence in getting to the bottom of the situation and spending the hours in going through the paperwork, making the phone calls and doing the research... to ultimately still finding out that the child that put the order was still at fault on our end... he still wanted to honor the situation and give us the money back... all that work, showed what type of businessman crostini’s was run by... I refused to except the money back because it was our fault ultimately… I give crostini’s pizza a five star review because any business that is run by such an honorable man with such wonderful food… Should be recognized by all! Thank you Joe... you have brought my faith back in humanity... your managerial skills, are top notch... I implore your honor, your business ethics, your food is delectable, overall, crostini’s is one of the greatest on Long Island INDEFINITELY!!! And I would recommend EVERYONE IN THE AREA or even you are just passing through to give joe a call... TRUST ME, you will definitely not be disappointed, his food is off...

I am so disappointed and will never eat here again. We have always ordered from here and even had catered food for family parties but the way I was spoken to today was disgusting! We had placed an order of chicken Franchese Heros with sauce on the side. When the food was delivered there was no sauce and a hero with Bearly any chicken and no sauce. When I called to have then bring the sauce they said they would charge me for a pint of sauce! Then when I called to speak to a manager a guy got on the phone who said the mamanger wasn’t in. I was trying to tell him my problem but he was talking over me and at the end he says they don’t make chicken franchises hero’s (which is false because we’ve ordered it from them Before) and then he said ... “Well what do you want me to do?” .... what do I want you to do? I’m a customer that has spent a lot of money at your establishment and would like new hero’s or sauce !...

Do you want the Long Island pizza experience? If yes, you're in the right place! The pizza by the slice is great, especially the buffalo chicken.

They had a good variety of pizzas and pizza adjacent foods. The prices were good and the place felt authentic.

If you've read this far then you probably know you'll like this place. The remainder of this review will be devoted to talking badly about Chicago style pizza.

Chicago pizza is for people who don't know what pizza is. It's like they read about it in a book and tried to recreate it.

Chicago pizza is for people who say they technically only had one piece, but one piece is 1600 calories.

Chicago pizza is great if you want to burn the roof of your mouth and feel uncomfortably full.

Chicago pizza is for people who like self inflicted heartburn, but they always act surprised they got...