Pizza snob here: I love all varieties of pizza but can tell if they’re not executed well, and this is excellent pizza! This is real “corner pizza place” pizza, no boutique styles like wood-fired Neapolitan, Detroit, or Sicilian here. But the different bake options give you a lot of variety, and easily outclass many local competitors. The thin crust is a better “NYC”-style slice than Cam’s, which can be too chewy, and the thick crust is a better “WNY”-style slice than Mark’s, as it’s lighter and fluffier. Unique sauce recipe stands out as an actual “topping” with a distinct flavor, as opposed to just a standard base, but without being overpowering. Sole (minor) complaint is that the “Crispy” bake turned out a little too chewy, and, like Cam’s, became fatiguing to chew after a slice or two, but this is easily avoided by sticking with the “Lightly Done” bake, so no worries there. Friendly, helpful staff who clearly take great pride in being a long-running family-owned business. Can’t wait to order...
Read moreWell... I bought pizza lunch last week the guy behind the counter was totally cool. He works a number of jobs and was interesting to talk to: 4 stars. When I took my wife for a pizza and wings dinner the next week and it was a different worker, to whom it presented an issue to split an order of wings into two different sauces. These are already $1.00 each wings. We gave a tip and in the end got the order, a little grudgingly. At 4:00pm it seemed we were eating the left over lunch slices: not bad, but not not at all fresh; cheese was re-congealed and crust was dry and very chewy. Also, to my taste, their atomic house was too ketchup-y, although that might be to the liking of some people. All that said, I'll probably give them another shot and get Buffalo atomic and order a fresh whole pizza and see how that goes. I'm told this is an awesome place so I don't want to judge it too quickly. But if it's the same worker, I'll...
Read moreMy daughter has soccer practice at the Game up the street and I have always told her we will get pizza from here “sometime” after practice.
Well today was that day. I ordered a large thin crust with pepperoni slightly well done online figuring we’d get drinks and eat it there when it was done so we could speed up the wait.
The ordering said 30 minutes. We got there after about 15 and it was already done. We grabbed the box and a drink and sat down.
This pizza looked good. I forgot to take a photo of it when I first opened the box so I took one after some of the pizza was chosen and eaten.
It was done perfect. Brown and crispy on the bottom but not burnt. The pepperoni are the type that curl up but not all the way. The sauce is good. It was a great pizza and hungry kids agree!
We enjoyed the pizza, our time here, and the guys who are working here are awesome.
We will be in again after practice I can...
Read more