Sami's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Sullivan

We ordered 2 pizzas (one with pepperoni and black olive, one with mushrooms and sausage) and 20 buffalo wings.

With 20 wings we got 2x 2oz containers of blue cheese that were half full. So basically 2oz of blue cheese for 20 wings. That would be awesome if you want to have 2-3 wings with blue cheese and the rest of them plain....but if your not a psychopath and want to actually have blue cheese will all or most or half more then 3 of your wings then too bad 😐.

As for the pizza they forgot the black olives on the black olive and pepperoni pie. It was really soggy, all flop, just honestly not good.

The mushroom and sausage pie was actually really good, crispy on the bottom and a good flavor.... Hence the two stars instead of one. I don't even know how both of these pies came from the same place, they seemed to be cooked completely different.

But seriously selling someone 20 wings and giving them 2oz of blue cheese should be federal crime. Are these wings for ants?....2oz of blue cheese couldn't even dress a small salad let alone 20 wings.

With that being said the wings were pretty good.... atleast the 3 that I had because I'm not a monster who's going to eat plain buffalo wings without...

Having recently moved here from Connecticut, it's been difficult to find a good pizza or calzone until we found Sami's! I ordered a Broccoli, sausage and garlic Calzone and the Hubs ordered Wings to be delivered.

Our order came 15 min early and was piping hot. The Wings were perfect; hot, extra crispy & light on the sauce. The Hubs was in Wing heaven. But my Calzone? Holy cow, it was HUGE! Not only did it hang off the plate but it was stuffed full of Broccoli, Italian Sausage and Garlic! Most places skimp on their fillings but not Sami's! And the marinara sauce tasted like gsrden fresh tomatoes and was the perfect accompaniment to the Calzone.

I was so impressed that I called them back and asked to speak to the guy who made my Calzone. The girl was hesitant but I assured her I was calling because it was delicious. Jimmy answered and I heaped praise on him for my delicious Calzone and he assured me the marinara was made fresh in store. I'm so happy I finally fou nd a local place with delicious Calzones and I'm hoping their pizza is equally as good.

Thank you Jimmy, for my delicious dinner. We'll definitely be...

Ok so I love this place..they have fantastic food and are usually VERY friendly and professional. This experience however was not the case. I stood at the counter waiting for someone to take my order while a young girl with a long blonde ponytail sat eating and ignoring me(I know she saw me).The other girl had to tell her to come take my order. I had to tell her twice what I wanted- no problem. But when I was being rung up they tried to charge me for extra food that I said I did not order. Ponytail basically called me a liar within 3 feet of me.. like I couldn't hear her?? And when she gave me my food I told her to have a good night she just said, "Yup." and walked away. Whoa.. Idk if she should be working the register. 🙄 Just put a bad taste in my...