Il Paradiso Pizza & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Wawarsing

Stopped in here on way to a family gathering nearby and had dinner. Sort of non-descript exterior, but I had read reviews that were good. The interior is pretty basic as well. We sat down near a window and pretty soon this jovial guy named Alan appears as if from nowhere, takes a seat at a table next to us and asks us what we are thinking to have. I realized then that he was our server. Very laid back and personable. We ordered the mussels as an ap; eggplant lasagna; a Caesar salad, an eggplant sub and fried calamari. The salad and mussels came out first and they were very good. The mussels had a marinara sauce that was loaded with chopped garlic and herbs. There were about a dozen mussels and they were so delicious. Both eggplant orders were excellent as well. The sub was definitely a two meal deal. The lasagna had layers of eggplant stuffed with ricotta, broccoli, mushrooms, tomatoes and spinach. Wonderful dish that easily could have served four. Breading did not overwhelm the eggplant nor mask it's taste. Again terrific sauce and cheese. The calamari were tender and delicious. This was a great meal in a place that serves fresh homemade...

I ordered a toasted salami sandwich from here. Thought no wrong could be done with something so simple. Well, they decided to throw in literally gray/green salami that tasted like it's been bad. I traveled for a night in town and this was the meal awaiting me considering I'm not from the area. Two bites and tasted off. I removed the bread to find this. Then I picked off most of the salami. Tried to eat whatever was left but could not stomach it. Only ate about a sixth of the sandwich. It was really gross and I've been feeling gross for the past 24 hours. Someone else purchased this for me while on my travel up. The person whom I was traveling with ordered a meatball sub, and told me their meatballs were not cooked all the way through, but again, this was our dinner for the night. They ended up not finishing their meal and feeling unwell as well to the point where they had gotten the runs a few hours later. Not only did I waste almost 30 dollars here on food that made me sick but that was literally our dinner for the night before staying up all night feeling awful. Never again will I trust to get food from here again when food safety isn't...

Ordered 1 large pepperoni pizza 1 large cheese pizza 3 orders of hot wings with extra hot sauce tossed on them was told I was given a special which included two 2 liters of soda I got a Mountain Dew and a Pepsi was told 1 hour for delivery after waiting a hour called and asked when my food would arrive was told that they told me over a hour but my food was on the way another hour passed when my food finally arrived the wings had barely any sauce on them there was 1 two liter of Mountain Dew no Pepsi and I received two Large cheese pies instead of 1 Large cheese and 1 large pepperoni 1 of the pizzas was folded in half in the box so we call back and they say let us make it right we will send the pepperoni pizza wing sauce and your Pepsi but the reason your pizza is folded in half we don’t have big enough boxes weird but ok anyways another hour goes by finally they show up by now my wings are ice cold but no worries they forgot to wing sauce yet again but we got the pepperoni pizza and the Pepsi I’m done with this place this isn’t the first time but it’s certainly the last time I waste money there! I been a loyal customer for years and I gave...