Spatola's Pizza Downingtown — Restaurant in Uwchlan Township

My wife and I are new to the area and have been trying out every pizza joint we can find. Coming from Conshohocken, we had a pizza place that was our sole provider for delicious round hunks of heaven. When we left, we were afraid we wouldn't be able to find a place comparable to our favorite shop. It's been a couple months of trial and error and I am so pleased to recommend Spatola's Pizza to everyone. I am sorry to myself and the pizza GODs that we didn't try them sooner. We order the same items from every shop we try ( our own little litmus test if you will ) One large cheese pizza, One Cheese Steak with fried onions and mushrooms, and an order of 25 Hot Wings. The pizza sauce was excellent as was the quality and quantity of cheese. I have to give the crust its own sentence because it makes the pizza. We were so tired of "bready" crusts or ones with no flavor or life to it. Spatola's crust offers an excellent chew, combined with a nice bite and pull. It's not flavorless either with its crisp edges, it provides a nice compliment. The cheese steak contained quality meat and cheese and was nicely filled. The roll was soft and obviously fresh and although we prefer harder rolls with more chew it was quite good. That's just a personal preference and does not negatively impact the sandwich. The wings were huge, delicious and spiced appropriately. In the future I think we will order them well done or fried hard as we like a little more crunch but again this is personal preference. Overall, excellent job Spatola's! You've gained yourself a couple of pizza eatin' fools. We will absolutely be back. Don't be fooled by half rate pizza joints in the area, if you haven't, give Spatola's a chance. If you don't like it, you don't know pizza! No personal preference...

Ordered a Trenton and a small cheese pizza, took an hour (though was told 30 min on phone). Trenton was overcooked, which was disappointing bc even though I like a crisp crust, burnt is a whole different and unappealing flavor. Overall, I found the Paoli location to be better.

My biggest concern is that they gave me the wrong pizza - I left with it and as I was pulling out, my kid checked and that's when we saw we had been given a large cheese instead. We returned, I opened the box again inside and showed them the wrong pie was inside, they closed the box and put it back on top of the oven to give to another person. Now, I'm not some psycho that did anything to the food, but it always creeps me out when restaurants pull that instead of trashing it (or sending it home with whoever they gave it to in error). Definitely gives me pause...

So, my husband and I are in love with your Greek Pizza. We love it. It's delicious. When I went to pick up my order today it wasn't ready, was never received on Spatola's end. Today wasn't the first day this has happened. Okay, fine whatever. I showed them the email I received after I placed my order. They asked me to write down my order. I did. They made it on the spot. Awesome! When I get home my large cheese pizza that was supposed to have half bacon and half pepperoni IS JUST CHEESE. I get half bacon and half pepperoni for my daughter because she specifically requests it. I wrote down my order so I don't even know how...