Casey's — Restaurant in Valparaiso

Love Casey's, however I have been here to the Calumet store a dozen times and they have had cigarettes I smoke in stock only 3 times, and the 3 times we have ordered pizza from there it was under cooked and doughy. I know this is a new store and there are some growing pains but if you want good Casey's pizza you will still need to go to the westville store. I don't know if they aren't measuring dough properly, or the oven converyor is too fast, or oven temp isn't as hot as it should be but we have been disappointed everytime with the pizza. Last time we took it back and they would only remake 1 of them as the other one "looked ok" even though I took it to work and had to throw it away because of how under cooked it was. I have talked to other people and they have had the same complaints of under cooked pizzas from here as well. I don't like the "other gas station" across the street but I am forced to go there because this store isn't in stock of items and the pizza which we love has...

My friend and I stopped at Casey’s this morning to grab a quick breakfast burrito and we we left soo satisfied and surprised! I myself had never tried any food from Casey’s but walking in, I saw an advertised sign showing Casey’s cheesy bread made from scratch for only $3.99. And although it was 8:30 in the morning I was feeling wild. The lovely woman crafted a delicious pie of cheesy bread with two sides of marinara and I was blown away with how tasty and fresh it was!!!!! Along with Cheesy bread there were so many other delicious options; sandwiches, coffee, donuts, muffins, salad and more! it all looked so tasty and fresh. Definitely going there next time i need a delicious, fresh meal. And huge thanks to the lovely and...

Ordered Barbecue Chicken Pizza... .WOW!! Delicious!! Loaded with white meat chicken. Bacon, onions, and just the right amount of bbq sause!! Oh ya lots of cheese too, for a gas station I couldn't believe my luck...I found my...