The Owl Wine & Food Bar — Restaurant in Washington

Maybe don’t make your pizza the star dish. I recently visited The Owl in New Preston, CT, and while the Bee Sting pizza showed some promise with its mozzarella, honey, soppressata, red pepper flakes, and red sauce, it ultimately fell flat. The flavor was passable, but the consistency was off—the texture was even worse than that of a frozen pizza, making it a disappointing experience for a pie that should have been a highlight.

On a brighter note, the Brussels sprouts, dressed in apple cider vinegar and truffle oil, were tasty and offered a redeeming quality amidst the otherwise lackluster fare. However, both dishes were outrageously overpriced. For a pizza that barely reaches 10 inches, a price tag of over $20 is unjustifiable when it should have been closer to $8. Similarly, while the Brussels sprouts were well-prepared, they too could have been priced below $17.

Given the steep prices and subpar quality, I’m definitely not returning to The Owl. If you’re craving a gourmet pie, I’d recommend trying Bohemian Pizza instead, or if you prefer a local favorite, Washington Pizza or Bantam Pizza might be a better bet. And as a friendly tip to The Owl: if you’re serious about improving your pizza, consider reaching out to Olivia—the previous tenant of the building known for her amazing mushroom Gorgonzola pizza—who has since moved her business to...

The Owl in New Preston, CT, is an absolute gem! From the moment you step inside, you are greeted by a warm and inviting ambiance that sets the tone for an exceptional dining experience. The staff here are incredible—friendly, attentive, and genuinely dedicated to making your visit memorable.

The leadership under Ryan is truly outstanding. His personal touch and friendly demeanor add a special charm to the restaurant. Ryan often takes the time to visit tables, ensuring that each guest feels welcomed and valued. His conversations are always a delight, and his passion for the restaurant is evident in every aspect of the dining experience.

The food at The Owl is nothing short of spectacular. Each dish is thoughtfully prepared, bursting with flavor, and beautifully presented. The menu offers a great variety, catering to all tastes and preferences.

Wait times are minimal, and the efficient service ensures that you can enjoy your meal without unnecessary delays. The attention to detail and the commitment to excellence are evident in every bite and interaction.

Overall, The Owl provides an unparalleled dining experience that combines excellent food, a wonderful ambiance, and top-notch service. It's no wonder this place is a favorite among locals and visitors alike....

The food itself was good, but the experience was completely soured by the owner’s rude and combative behavior.

We ordered the bread pudding, but it arrived without silverware. After repeatedly asking several members of the wait staff, we finally received utensils—by which time the ice cream had already melted. Our waiter was kind enough to offer a fresh scoop and took the dessert away to replace it.

About ten minutes later, a man I assume was the owner came over—not with our dessert, but to tell us they were “out” of bread pudding. When I asked what happened to the one we had just sent back for ice cream, I was shocked to hear that it had been given away to another table.

When I questioned why our dessert had been handed to someone else instead of simply fixing it, the owner immediately became defensive, snapping at me that there was “no need to have an attitude” and making snarky remarks instead of addressing the issue. His tone was unnecessarily combative and extremely unprofessional.

Even our server later profusely apologized for the owner’s poor behavior. Unfortunately, the damage was done. The food may be decent, but the management’s attitude was so appalling that I would strongly caution anyone...