Classico Tomato Pies — Restaurant in West Windsor

For the cheese curly fries, the cheese is put right on top of the fries so the fries were very soggy by the time we got home (just a quick drive away). We tried to reheat them in our toaster oven/air fryer to help, but because the cheese was on top and inseparable, that didn't help either. Far more frustratingly though, I specifically called before ordering to ask if the arancini could be made without beef to be vegetarian, and was told yes and to just write it in the notes. So I did exactly that when placing the order, writing "Vegetarian (no beef)." After picking up the order and getting home, I took a few bites of it and realized there is beef in there. I immediately called the restaurant and the same man who I had spoken to before ordering picked up the phone - he said he didn't know if there was or wasn't beef in it, and did not even apologize when I told him there was. He said he could not refund but we could drive back there and pick something else up, or have store credit for next time. It was incredibly upsetting - I have never eaten beef in my entire life for religious reasons, and became vegetarian and have not consumed any meat at all in over 4 years. I had stomach pain and significant nausea that night after eating those few inadvertent bites, likely because my body hasn't digested meat in so long. It's just incredibly frustrating that I called ahead to confirm, wrote it clearly in the notes, and still ended up inadvertently consuming beef contrary to my order - and then did not even receive anything anywhere near an apology. We always strive to support local WWP businesses, but this was unfortunately a truly awful experience I can't...

Overall very bad experience..We ordered two pizza today Mumbai Pie and the regular cheese pizza.

1. The price on their website for large is listed for $21 and at the time of paying at the counter they charged $23. When I asked, the answer I got was website is NOT updated. No apologies or did not even try to match the price or did not put any efforts to convey this to the customer about price discrepancy in a subtle way.
2. When I ordered it over the phone, I clearly said medium cheese pizza and medium Mumbai pie. As per website medium is listed for $14. But at the time of payment, they charged $23 for Mumbai pie and when questioned they said Mumbai pie comes only in one size. When I said medium on the phone why would you NOT mention that it comes only in one size (large)? deceptive way to get customers to the door and then charge more.
3. I still went ahead and paid thinking maybe their food is good. I did not put up fight for the price discrepancy.
4. Now comes the food part: Mumbai pie is a joke. The entire pie was overcooked and crust was burnt and the pizza was super crispy and it came in the pizza shape and look but no where close to the pizza taste. See the attached burnt pizza pics
5. Cheese pizza could have been better if NOT for super crispiness which I think may be due to overcooked and the crust burnt.

Not worth $40 for a medium and a large pizza.

Now if the owner respond's and say we did not find any customer with this name, then look up the check#159 ordered 11/05/21 @ 8;18 PM and name starts with letter "M"

Overall never tasted such bad pizza and NO i am NOT...

I've heard some good things and some bad things about Classico Tomato Pies. I finally decided to give them a try for myself. Unfortunately, it was the bad things that made for my experience there.

First and foremost, the restaurant itself was very spacious and inviting, and the service was very friendly and fast! That is always a good thing, no matter where you go!

As always, I ordered a large, PLAIN tomato pie. No toppings!! They simply mask the flavor of a good pizza! When the pie arrived, it sadly did not look too promising. Right away I could see puddles of grease all over the top of the pie. Upon picking up my first slice, the tip bent over and the grease began to drip off..... bad news.... I simply don't understand why pizza places think that an overabundance of cheese, or cheap cheese at that is acceptable?? One good note was that the sauce had a nice balance of sweetness and tartness to it. I couldn't really get a fix on the dough because it had absorbed a lot of the grease from the cheese.

Maybe I went to Classico on an off night, I dont know. I'm sure there are people out there who rave about this place, and that's fine. I do not see myself making the 45 min drive back up to give it...