York Fish & Oyster Co — Restaurant in West York

Wow. What an overpriced market for not so fresh fish. Went in to buy a salmon for dinner. Filets looked old so asked for a whole fish. 11 pounds $115 So I asked them to filet it. Took some time but then came back and said it was now$220. $105 to filet a fish??? They explained they already have filets out so premium is for fresh. Lol. Never heard of that. Then as I walked out the guy that cut up the fish opened the back foot with a cigarette in his mouth flipped me off and told me to F* myself because I didn’t take it. Lol. No wonder this place is going out of business and has such old...

We usually get oysters here and are always pleased with the quality! There is always prompt service and the folks are always friendly. They aleays have an amazing selection of fresh and frozen seafood. Prices are reasonable.

Edited 9/23/23: visited there today mid afternoon, which is the time we typically visit. Very sad compared to how it used to be. Virtually no selection and as expected with this economy the prices have gone up. Selection is down to 1/3 of what they used to have. Service was fine, quality seemed...

Dissatisfied!!! I asked for fresh crab meat non pasteurized. Fresh not frozen. I got home to a pre frozen slacked out crab meat. It was fully loaded and drenched saturated in juice the crab meat tasted horrible. Lost my business first time getting seafood and the last. Thought I found a nice place apparently not. Asking the lady if it was any good and quality she relied we have hi standards here I trusted...