Pepperoni's — Restaurant in Winter Park

How anyone gives this place less than 5 stars is beyond me. Been coming here for years just for the pizza and service. This is the last local feeling place on the mountain. Makes you feel like Mary Jane is still the good ol’ Mary Jane it used to be. The slices are always big and at $5 it’s the best deal on the mountain. The mug club is on point if you are a beer drinker. Then you have Tiff (bartender) who always gives us the best of service. That’s not to leave out the other employees here whom are fantastic, I’m simply bad with remembering names. Thanks to all! Get here early cause this place is always slammed, and rightfully so. It’s the last locals haven on the whole mountain…. Hers to hoping for many more years of...

Seems like it could be a cool place. Have been eyeing it for weeks. Almost no pizza ready and bartender was not the friendliest. Asked if they had more cheese pizza and she said it would be awhile (I here were 3 pizzas uncooked right next to the oven, she put in the meat one next even though there was already plenty of pepperoni and no cheese) I would rather spend a few dollars more and get better food and service elsewhere. I see one of the options for this review is “vegetarian options” definitely not...

Overall: If you want outstanding pizza at WP, go to Pizza Pedal’r instead. There’s a reason their reviews are better ;)

In terms of Pepperoni’s restaurant, I used to like this place because of their local atmosphere and big pizza slices.

To join the fun, I bought a “lifetime mug club” membership at the end of last year. But now, they no longer honor it. I don’t think the “lifetime mug club” was originally meant to be a scam…but in the...