Smithville Peanut Butter Company — Attraction in Galloway Township

I came here with my mom the other day and the peanut butter is amazing. The pb cookie was so good as well. I'm knocking off three stars because as I was checking out, there was a person in the back (through the doorway directly behind the register) who was clipping their finger nails just right there at the counter, in full view of customers. I said something to the guy checking me out and he just shook his head and and made a comment along the lines of "tell me about it", which implied this is a common occurrence. Anyone who clips their nails knows that no matter how hard you try, they go flying. To do that in a kitchen where food is being baked and sold to the public is...

Yeppppp.... this is peanut/nut butter heaven. I love how simple this place is but SO perfect. Yes, the prices are going to be more than your average "Jiffys" from the grocery store. You are paying for HIGH QUALITY, GOURMET nut butters - its worth it!! These nut butters are for die hard fans. Creamy, thick, sweet, you name it- they have it. Love the variety of flavors & PB themed...

I loved the Butter Scotch flavored peanut butter the are selling. Its the first store I visited when we came into the village. The have a taster for all their bestseller and I can say the butterscotch is very yummy! The lady at the counter was so friendly & helpful with our questions. I would love to come back...