Keepsake Consignment — Local services in Madison

I have to say, I was pleasantly surprised by Keepsake Consignment. Shopping for Men’s apparel in consignment/thrift stores like this is usually a bust. Clothing never fits, is super ugly, or is way too expensive.

Keepsake hit the sweet spot for me- the perfect mix of price, quality and style. 👏 I bought some fantastic additions to my wardrobe here that I am super pumped about.

Also, big shoutout to the woman working there (maybe the owner?) She was super professional and friendly with all of the customers, greeted me instantly, and gave me a quick rundown of where to find everything when I walked in.

Keep at it Keepsake Consignment! Will definitely be returning next time I’m in...

I haven't been in a while but used to go regularly, overall it's a great second hand consignment shop, and the owner I believe her name is Tammy is such a nice lady, they have top name brands, I have found a lot and have bought alot, I stopped going due to gaining alot of weight due to health problems and it's very hard to find the bigger size clothes here, I would definitely go back and be a regular again if they had more large extra large shirts, great place for nice quality name brands such as PINK, Hollister, American Eagle, almost everything you can find...

While the store was clean, the prices are a little high for the area. I'm not sure how you justify selling single shoes, not pairs for prices 10-20% over what pairs of shoes would cost. I'm making assumptions, so discredit what I'm about to say if you want, but it looks like the clothing is purchased cheaply at a goodwill or salvation army and sold for a much higher price here. I'm sure it's not true, but the brands and clothes seem similar to both...