Cleveland Card Co. — Local services in Mentor

A True Gem in the Sports Card World!

Cleveland Card Co. is hands-down one of the best in the business. Rob and his team are the absolute life of the sports card industry — passionate, knowledgeable, and always going above and beyond to deliver an amazing experience. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just getting started, they treat every customer like a VIP.

What really sets them apart is their lightning-fast shipping — cards are always packed with care and arrive quicker than expected. And the selection? Top-notch. You can always count on finding quality cards and some real gems that you won’t see anywhere else.

I’ve have the pleasure of buying from rob on a regular basis and I can tell you he brings unmatched energy, integrity, and heart into everything Cleveland Card Co. does. This is more than a business — it’s a team that genuinely loves the hobby and its community.

If you're into sports cards, this is where you want to be. Big respect to Rob and the crew ,keep doing what you do!

Also if you have Whatnot follow them on whatnot app...

Not a place to do business. Is essentially just a warehouse for their WhatNot repacks. Little inventory for purchase compared to most shops I’ve been too. Scammers for how low their floor cards are on WhatNot. $25 floors for average bids of $90-$100. Never make it clear at all for new streamers the floor or ceiling for each break in show notes to explain how it works for new people. Won’t respond to messages in a timely manner, especially when I asked to do pickup instead of shipping since I live less than 30 minutes away. Since I didn’t spend thousands of dollars I guess they can’t “hook me up” like they do for other customers. Such a shame since the opening night trade event was so much fun and I met some cool people. Will not be recommending this place to anyone I know at local shops. Shameful this business is part of such a great card community I...

So first this review is based on my experience of lack of reliability of the shop. I personally have never met or talked to, or been inside said shop. I tried a couple weeks ago to come by and the were closed.. sure it happens. Then I tried over the weekend. Saw they were at sport show, ok underandable. The to day 8-5 the day the were to re open they were closed when I got there at 625. Pm. So I dont think I will attempt to go back when there are other shops in area that are just more efficient and reliable. I do. Wish the Cleveland card co. The best in there journey for the future. They are just...