Carvel — Local services in Town of Islip

First time there ,last time there 9.75 for a large shake that was in a medium size cup .i asked for a Vanilla shake with peanut butter syrup. I never tasted the peanut butter ..waaaay high prices and didnt get what i asked for ..there were signs of brown/ peanut butter in the cup . I noticed when i took the lid off but still never tasted it..carvel in centereach has large cups and put peanut butter in it so you can taste it ..very...

Every time I go into this shop, they find a way to charge me more than their posted prices. We stopped going there in the past due to same issue, but I thought I would give them another try. Nope. Same result. Got charged 50 cents extra on a child size cup for it being a "limited time flavor." The upcharge wasn't listed on any if the advertising. Buyer beware. Done...

I ordered the largest cake with a picture on it totaling to 65$ I picked the cake up 1 hour before the party and when I got there, my daughters name was spelt wrong! They tried to fix it and it looked horrible and they still charged me...