Godfathers Pizza - Cayuga — Restaurant in Ontario

Unimpressed first time, and last time visit!

Ordered on a Friday evening for dinner during travel. Order was incorrect when I arrived to pick it up. Missing two orders of garlic fingers. They quickly threw some in the over to correct the mistake. Ordered 2 mediums, 2 small garlic fingers and a 2L beverage. Get the full order and leave. Toppings are incorrect on one of the medium pizza’s. It’s too late to go back and correct and wait for this all to be remade. Both pizzas and garlic fingers are over cooked and dry. Garlic fingers were basically burnt cheese on a thin hard crust. Both medium pizzas were burnt cheese, sparse toppings just like dry day old pizza. Won’t be back. Not worth wasting my money. I wouldn’t recommend this place given my experience. Staff hanging out on their phones. Clearly not caring about customer service, providing the correct orders or quality of the...

worst experience. Ordered pick up based on current flyer. Arrived and they said price was higher and that i had an old flyer. Pointed to wall which had the same special. They then said higher price was because i ordered chicken on pizza. i assumed like most places it would count as two toppings. They told me when i arrived instead of over the phone that chicken is an extra $3 dollars regardless of how many toppings ordered. i wont be taken advantage of and...

This godfathers is a takeout pizza shop with limited bench seating inside. It is very clean and the staff is friendly. Always get my order right and the food is consistently good. Besides pizza I’ve had wings and cheesy bread sticks from here without any complaints, very tasty! Fair prices. There’s street parking out front and have never had a...