Bullseye Pub & Eatery — Restaurant in Algonquin

Nothing makes this place stand out positively or negatively. Like most local pubs, this place almost ignores you if you are not a regular. I have gone 3 times in the past month. First time the floor and table were sticky. Getting a drink and menu took effort. The 2nd visit I walked in and there were no customers, no kitchen working, and dart area was closed. Why stay?? 3rd visit still no kitchen, and to get a drink I had to go to the kitchen that was not open to find a person to get me a drink. Getting a drink at a bar should not be this difficult. I understand the kitchen remodel.... But if the kitchen is closed, why is the bartender hanging back there with customers out front?? Once I found a server, my beer was nice and cold. Nothing here is terribly wrong... It just has not been quite right. Hopefully the kitchen and menu reboot energizes this place. I want the local pub to be a place where...

I would never have expected to give a high rating for this reason... I opted for a side salad with my wrap sandwich. It looked acceptable but unexceptional - decent mix of greens, carrot shavings, tomato, and the obligatory croutons.

But these were the most amazing croutons I have ever had in my life. Instead of the usual stale crunch, they melt in the mouth with just enough crisp feel to declare "Yes, I'm a bit of seasoned toasted bread, ain't that grand?"

We went late-ish on a Friday evening. Service could have been better, but in all fairness it appeared they were short staffed. At 7pm pizza and burgers were sold out, which suggests they are worth arriving early. While indoor seating was available, we opted for outside. Plenty of tables, good spacing, nice atmosphere.

I'll be going back to the Bullseye. If the burgers are as good as the croutons, they're the best burgers...

Went there on Valentine’s Day around 10pm. Was not busy at all. We ordered a few alcoholic drinks, wings, and an entree (so around $50 right there), then around 10:45 my husband decided to order food. We told the waiter we had a free entree coupon. He said no problem. My husband placed his order, then a couple minutes later the waiter came back and told us the manager said kitchen is closed. We were a little bummed, but then my husband said we would like to order a desert (had a coupon for that also). The waiter said no can do. Mind you, he/they had no problem taking our order UNTIL we mentioned we had a coupon. The margarita was $8 and TINY, the wings tasted weird and way over-seasoned, the only decent thing was my husband’s appetizer. The waiter was pretty arrogant as well. Oh well, we won’t be...