Andy's Pizza — Restaurant in Aynor

This place is awful! The staff messed everything on my order up. I won't go back again! It was almost like they weren't right in the head! I called in an order, went to pick it up. The lady at the window charged me and gave me the wrong order. I pulled up, took the order inside and told her this isn't my order. She recharged me for my order and handed me the wrong order back again. I handed it back to her and she handed me my order. I get my pizza home and it isn't even sliced into slices. Just a whole pizza in a box. Then I opened the box of wings I ordered. The garlic/parmesan wings I ordered were just plain wings, no sauce on them. How do you mess up so many times on one order? Something isn't right! I absolutely do not...

I stopped in this morning on recommendation of someone I had business with earlier. I walked into a very clean place and later understood why. The waitress was friendly and attentive and promptly took my order. I went with a supreme pizza. While I was waiting at my table the waitress spent her downtime cleaning in the dining area. Any time she passed she was smiling and talked to me even suggesting cheesecake for dessert. The pizza was very good and I ate more of it than I plained Even tho I live 35 minutes away, I’ll definitely be back and get a large pizza next time so I can take some home with me and yes, to try...

I have eaten here a few times, but have yet to be blown away by anything other than their prices, which for the quality, I personally think is kind of high. Many people rave over it, and I have given it several chances, maybe Im missing something. I guess if you like cheese pizza or pepperoni pizza, well, you cant really mess that up I suppose, and it is fairly priced. Hot wings werent very tasty to me neither. To tell you the truth, Hunts Pizza at the local gas station is better pizza in my book, but to each is his own. Service has always been decent, just missing that wow factor everyone...