Fatheads Pizza — Restaurant in Batesville

Saw the sign and decided to knock another restaurant off our bucket list. Interior boasts a variety of seating options from at bar seating to high top tables to standard table seating. Relatively large, open dining space with numerous big screens, sports decor, and wood details throughout. There's even a brick fireplace that made it feel even more homey. We ordered the Rotel dip and chips, Large Mexican pizza, and a half order of the Supreme salad. Everything we ordered tasted amazing and arrived temperature hot. Heads-up: If you're expecting tortilla chips with the cheese dip, then skip this appetizer. If you're okay with potato chips, then go ahead and order it. Service was exceptional, food was delicious, and the environment was laid-back, comfy, and clean. This place kind of reminded me of a mix between US Pizza company and Pizza Cafe. Only negative I have would be the Womens bathroom (I used the one upfront by the main entry doors). No stall doors. Just 2 open toilets separated by a partition. I even locked the main door, which as luck would have it didn't actually lock as I had a few teenage girls walk-in on me mid-pee 🤦‍♀️🤣🙃🤷‍♀️ Other than that,...

We really wanted to love this place, but unfortunately the food just didn’t live up to the price. The flavors were very bland and the quality was a bit disappointing. On top of that, the strong smell of cleaning products when we walked in really killed my appetite right away.

That said, the service was excellent and our waiter was so kind and attentive, and that’s the main reason I gave an extra star. I appreciate the effort on that end, but sadly the food experience just wasn’t enough for us to want...

Being born and raised in Chicago i have high expectations for pizza when I go out for pizza and this place met them and beyond!! Crust is on point for a thin crust and the sauce 😋 👌 was amazing. Great prices and they have other menu items as well if you dont want just a pizza! Definitely highly...