Scratch Ice Cream — Restaurant in Brookfield

If I could give it 2 additional stars I would. This place is so good, I'm surprised lines aren't going out the door!!! I have never had ice cream so smooth and packed with flavor. Every flavor I sampled was better than the last, non-dairy flavors too! The salted caramel waffle cone is PERFECT, the right amount of salt against the caramel so it's not overpowering but perfectly balanced (did I say perfect?), The waffle cone pieces have a flavor all their own and the right amount of density when you bite into them- not crumbly but not chewy, they break apart like you're eating them fresh but are coated with the ice cream just right.

As if that wasn't awesome in itself, the mint oreo is so fresh, Oreo chunks throughout and has a creaminess all it's own you wouldn't even miss the dairy factor. I had both of these in the same dish (wondering why I didn't ask for them in different dishes), and EACH flavor held up against the other.

Is this the best ice cream I've ever had? Yes, yes it is. I would highly recommend you get in if you haven't and get some pints to go because the next time you come, the lines will most likely be long (but still very much...

Seriously some of the best ice cream ever! The staff is well mannered as well. Super expensive as well though. A pint is about twice the price of a grocery store, the 2 scoop costs more than the pint which doesn’t seem right at all. Their pricing is very unclear on pints and “custom pints” the workers seem to change it up all the time , very inconsistent, it would be easier for everyone to just have a set price for them all together. Also I called ahead outside as it was raining to ask questions and no customers were in the store, there were 3-4 employees but no one answered the phone. It would be nice if they had a virtual flavor roster for the day to attract more attention. Overall some of the best ice cream in Wisconsin! Go try it 😄 and especially get...

Cute ice cream shop. Expensive, but good quality. A nice treat. I am dairy free and LOVE their oat milk ice "cream," but was recently disappointed by the rapeseed vegan ice "cream". The oat milk version is an amazing dupe for lacrosse intolerant or vegan folks, but the rapeseed one is like an oily sorbet with a weird after taste. For the first time there, ever, I couldn't finish my scoop. Some problem with their supplier, I was told. I'll wait for the oat milk ones to return to go back. My family was happy, as usual, with the cow milk ice creams they ate. And the young lady working was helpful,...