Sister's Island Cuisine — Restaurant in City of Middletown

First time I had their food the Oxtail was excellent. Second time you could tell they struggled to keep up the good consistency with it. Third time I was extremely dissatisfied which happened to be my last. My wife picked up some large Oxtail dinners and to our surprise the bill was astronomical. $60 plus for two large oxtail plates and a large Stew chicken. Well let’s just say they put plenty of bones with little to no meat in both plates of oxtail. Not enough in two plates for an actual large plate. I’ve eaten at plenty of Jamaican spots so I know what is a decent portion, then the meat that was there wasn’t trimmed properly where there was so much fat on it still I felt like they didn’t trim it at all. Then there was a river of grease at the bottom of my rice that flowed back and forth like a water current. Very poor oil portions and fat trimming. We both felt sick after trying to eat around all the bones, oil and fat. Rice wasn’t that good either but passable at best. The meat and gravy I did eat had good flavor but in the end we felt like we waisted our money just to feel sick afterwards. I wish I had taken the photo of the food b4 I cleared the plate. I’m just...

I've had dinner twice from here,,, the jerk chicken, rice with peas, sweet plantains, and steamed cabbage and a Arizona Iced Tea. I have zero complaints. Everything was seasoned well and they give you plenty. Everything I mentioned was less than $20 dollars and I paid with my debit card, not sure if there's a price difference with cash. Either way, where are you going to eat dinner for less than $20 dollars and it's all cooked from scratch, can't even go get fast food in the equal amount of food they give for that price. The restaurant is very clean, you can smell the food when you go in and there's a variety of food to choose from. Get there early cause if you want oxtail it goes quick, but there's plenty of food to choose from. You will not be disappointed I can assure you that. I highly recommend checking this place out, bring your family and bring your appetite or you will have lunch for the next day. The staff is pleasant, it's clean and nice to get a home cooked meal not some processed garbage from the chain restaurants around here. By the way I ordered a "Large" so that's the size you see in the picture I posted, but they have medium and small so order...

Just moved to the area and of course one the first things we Caribbean people do is look for our traditional foods that make us feel like home 🏡 Sister's island Cuisine did not disappoint! Obviously they're doing something right because if you don't come early enough, they might not have what you're looking for. The Jerk Chicken was authentically prepared in the black barrel drum they have right in front of the establishment. The cow foot was like butter melting of the bones literally. Even for the medium stew chicken and rice and peas portions were very generous and felt like a Brooklyn or Queens large. I also ordered the curry goat and rice (medium) dish which didn't survive for leftovers. No chance. I like the spicey steamed cabbage which was laced with scotch bonnet. That was a very unique twist and a first for me. Absolutely 💯 loved it. Would I highly recommend or go back myself?!!! I'm already there! If you're in the area, I would say this a gem 💎 when you're in the mood for west Indian food and you don't feel like...