Niagara Creamery — Restaurant in Erie

Visited Niagara Creamery on an out of town visit. It was the BEST ice cream I’ve ever tried. Truly everything was a 10/10. The location was quaint- a covered “patio” area, bench style tables and nice Adirondack style chairs. The prices were awesome and especially fair given the freshness and uniqueness of the flavors. We didn’t try it today, but I found the “ice cream flight” (4- 2 oz servings) option to be super cool and unique! The owners allowed us quite a few samples- one equally as delicious after another. We landed on the banana pudding (recommended with hot fudge and caramel by one of the owners) as well as the blackberry cheesecake. My daughters got classic chocolate and their “slushie fusion”, which was also something I hadn’t seen before! A traditional slushie mixed with vanilla ice cream- yum! While we waited for our orders we happily chatted with the owners who were just plain warm and inviting. We heard the story of their passion for the business and even their love of the Great Dane mascot out front- Dobby. As a small business the connection with customers is so important and they nailed this! All in all the flavors were fresh (so much of their menu is home made using fresh ingredients!) and simply amazing. Anytime I visit Erie again I’ll be sure to come again! I wish them nothing...

Stopped here today with my family. The workers are extremely nice. The ice cream I had was the best I have ever tasted. The flavor was outstanding. I had a milkshake, it was delicious. I get to taste my wifes sundae vanilla with chocolate syrup, peanut butter cup ice cream with pecans, OMG, it was absolutely amazing. My daughter had a flurry with caramel and Oreo, it was super delicious. My mother-in-law had a cake cone with raspberry cheesecake ice cream, she said it was delicious and the flavor was very impressive. We madea point to let the staff know how much we appreciate them and how much we enjoyed our treat. Highly recommend this place, the work hard and definitely make the very best ice cream treats. Can't wait to return next year as we live pretty far away in Washington, Pennsylvania. Great job by all, keep up...

Best locally made gourmet ice cream in Erie!! Located in the heart of Erie's East side amongst neighboring homes and businesses...just love the hometown feel of it. Kids riding up on their bikes, college kids taking a break, tourists looking for dessert and dog owners bringing their pups (and themselves), for a cool treat. Erie summertime doesn't get any better than this.

On day one, I had the banana pudding ice cream in a crunchy fresh waffle cone...perfection. Then, I came back for day two, and had a scoop of the mint chocolate chip ice cream in a generous cup. Took home a huge homemade chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich filled with vanilla ice cream (they are custom made with whatever flavor you want in the middle). 😎. Support this Erie locally owned and operated ice cream shop ...you are in for a...