Tyler's Homemade Ice Cream — Restaurant in Florida

I needed to write this review in the beginning of this year, and kept forgetting. I want to let the owners of Tyler's Homemade Ice Cream know, not only do they have excellent ice cream, but they have a wonderful employee who made our experience great! It was a holiday, New Year's Day, and I was surprised they were open. We decided to stop for an ice cream after a day at the beach. The parking lot was almost full, but we decided we were in no hurry and would wait for service as it would most likely be slow. Inside there were quite a few people, and only one young lady who was serving. She patiently handed samples from the large variety of flavors as requested. She scooped and served and had the most pleasant attitude. She made us feel welcome and did not falter from any pressure of the waiting customers. We were served surprisingly fast and enjoyed not only the delicious ice cream, but the entire experience. I will not hesitate to stop again, as we frequent the local beach. I hope the attending young lady...

I have been thinking about their ice cream since I had it last summer, and finally had the chance to grab some to go. I got chocolate chip cookie dough because last time it was AMAZING, this time I was so disappointed! I'm not exaggerating when I say that there were only maybe 5 or 6 small pieces of cookie dough in the whole two scoops. And about 10 chocolate chips. It was practically just vanilla. If I wanted plain vanilla thats what I would order. Store bought ice cream has more add ins in it and I could of gotten a whole gallon for the same price. It sucks because their ice cream was always so good. I also always recommend them because I work at a nearby establishment, but I dont know if I will...

Nothing special. Young girls without much personality scoop icecream and take your money. Heard good things about this place, ice cream was good. That was about it. The location is good for those on the south end of Anna Maria Island. The 2 ice cream shops on the north end of the island were always Very busy with long lines. Holy Cow ice cream shop at least offered up some conversation and actually seemed truly interested in making the visit an experience. Tyler's we felt like we were almost an inconvenience. Just over the bridge on the mainland, and literally around the corner from some well known and well regarded restaurants that are...