Caking at Midnight — Restaurant in Fort Wayne

Caking at Midnight is amazing! They have a true passion for baking! If you have an idea for cookies or a cake – send it to them and they can make it happen! I am not sure how they do it but sometimes the cookies or cake are even better than the idea I have!!!

Not only are the bakery items beautiful, they are always beyond delicious. I never have leftovers! One year I took cutout cookies from Caking at midnight to Florida for my Granddaughter’s 2nd birthday. They were such a hit, delicious and super cute Mermaids and Unicorns! I have been mailing cookies to them every year since!

If you love German Chocolate Cake, try theirs! You will not be disappointed – I am addicted!!

Caking at Midnight could write a book about customer service! They do what they say they will (or more!) and when they say they will – AMAZING! I recently had a flat tire near their new store on Main Street in Fort Wayne. They were so kind to stop and help me get going again! I bet there are not many Bakeries who can say they have done that! I am a lifer customer!

Sue...

Ordered cake for 10/26/2024 picked up day before upon arrival cake was brought out. Was told that the order was miss placed and she tried to make it by memory. Ordered half sheet cake yellow cake chocolate icing normally half sheet cakes are one layer. Was told she does half sheet cakes by stacking. Looks like a quarter of a sheet cake we should have been told this during the ordering not a pick up. Wanted the words love your daughters on the cake not on the card board. If you forgot the order I would have picked up the phone and called the Customer to make sure I get what they wanted correct not go by memory. First time last time. Would not recommend. I have photo of cake if you would like to see it. 75.00 for this. And it wasn’t...

We visited to order cake pops for my daughter's baby shower. They had some available for tasting, and they exceeded expectations. Notably, they were the largest cake pops I've ever seen, with fondant that provided a perfect crunch before reaching the moist and flavorful cake interior. Although I'm not typically fond of fondant, theirs was delicious. The establishment was immaculately clean and aesthetically pleasing. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable. The owner, who was working in the back, took the time to assist us personally when we asked a question, helping us make a decision about decorating the cake pops. We're looking forward to enjoying their treats during our...