Coffaros' Pizza — Restaurant in Grove City

Ordered carryout pizza that was ready in 20 minutes. Arrived at the designated time and the pizza was just out of the oven. The crust was fresh made and cooked nicely, brown and crusty on the ends, but firm and chewy throughout, very evenly cooked. The toppings were very good, though fresh sliced mushrooms would have been preferred over the canned mushrooms. That was the only criticism as the pizza was really good. I did prefer it to other pizzas available in the area as the crust elevated it to the top position. Definitely more of a traditional pizza than the other places from a Midwest perspective. Will definitely have to return! Price was very reasonable at under $20 for a large 3 topping pizza. Service for carry out was immediate...

I had to reach out and give a little bit of credit because this is some of the best pizza and sides we have had in such a long time from anywhere local. We had a couple orders of their hot wings which were cooked perfectly, and the seasoning was very good, as well as an order of their jalapeño poppers and fried mushrooms, which were again fantastic and we had a few pizzas, chicken bacon ranch, a meat, lovers and a deluxe and I don’t give reviews very often but I will tell you this everything was delicious. Come to find out they are locally owned as well. Give them a shot, you will not be disappointed. We appreciate your dedication to good food and your delivery service...

I just moved to the area and I suffer from Gerd & celiac disease. 25% of the time they deliver the pizza non-gluten free and I have to drive over and return it and they replace it (thankfully), but mostly not even an apology even though it could have risked my life to consume.

The other 75% is then forgetting to add pepperoni, even if we order 2 pepperoni pizzas - one will come with and one will come with none. How the hell does “two pepperoni pizzas” = one with and one without. Trust me, they aren’t out of pepperoni, they just say “we forgot”.

Me and my partner order from there 2 times a month and it’s either A) Missing an item or B) Not...