Gaslight Pizza & Grill — Restaurant in Huntingburg

Very disappointed in your establishment and your staff. Decided to try your pizza for the first time and when we ordered the waitress that took or order misunderstood our order due to how noisy it was inside. We ordered a pepperoni and beef pizza. When the pizza came out I noticed it had onions all over so I asked her and told her I don't like onions and it was full of onions and plus it didn't have any pepperoni on it. She went into the kitchen and came back and told me I had ordered a cheeseburger pizza and it came with onions. I told her again what we had order and she had the nerve to call me a lier more less and told me she heard me order that pizza and I told I did not and she kept arguing and telling me I did. She went and talked to the manager and comes back and tells me I have to pay for this wrong pizza alone with with the new one they have to make. I told her I was not paying for the messed up pizza because she misunderstood what I had said and she argueing again with me. Finally she came back and said that they will not charge me this time but next time they will charge me. At that point who wouldn't of been mad and upset. I told her to cancel the order I would take my business elsewhere and would never be back. First time I have even been to a resturant and the staff call me a lier and they expect me to pay for...

Best freaking Philly I've had in long time.

We went here at 15 minutes til closing on Wednesday night and these 3 gentlemen welcomed us with open arms. They didn't seem irritated or frustrated. We dined in and had a wonderful time.

This place was amazing we were from out of town and had just got there and checked into our hotel 15 minutes before and wanted something to eat and we found this place and Boy are we glad.

My husband got a pizza and I got a Philly and it was literally the best we've had in a super long time. I commend these men for their excellent customer service skills and they way they handle the flattop.

We went back a couple days later (we're staying 3 nights down there) and my husband got the Philly and I got the chicken parm and I wasn't as impressed with the chicken parm I was hoping it was going to be breaded but the spaghetti sauce taste like it's homemade and it was delicious. So no real complaints besides I probably didn't read throughly.

Either way this place is hands down a must try I just wish it was closer to my home town or they would mail us some Phillys...

Our waitress never checked on us, service was slow even though there were only 8 tables (maybe 20-25 guests) and 3 waitresses. I ordered the Italian sandwich which was marked as a specialty and it was really pretty bad. Also I asked the waitress what came on it because nothing is listed in the menu and she just said she didn’t know. My biggest complaint with the sandwich is that they wrapped it in aluminum foil while it was very hot before bringing it out which caused everything to steam and be mushy including the lettuce and tomato. I believe the only meat on the sandwich was ham and there was an orange cheese (probably cheddar) so this was more of a ham and cheese sandwich with Italian dressing in it. Really disappointing for an item marked as a specialty. However my wife got the tortellini and it was really good and the kids did not complain. Pizza prices seemed kinda high but everything else was really reasonable. Atmosphere/decor...