Nicola's Pizza — Restaurant in Lambertville

This place is from a bygone era, and it’s an era that should never have gone away. I walked in there with my extended family and was immediately transported to my childhood in NJ. The staff is awesome. The ambiance is fantastic - zero frills, just straight up old school pizzeria. We ordered our pies, and when they arrived I was giddy. Took a slice, and it was heaven. Crust was crispy on the bottom, cheese was practically liquid, just a molten triangle of excellence. I ate 4 slices. I’ve been thinking that my local place in Maryland is great, because it REMINDS me of this kind of pizza. My memories have definitely faded over time, because this pizza was just otherworldly. The best. Nothing special in the sense that it’s fancy. It’s exactly what I think of when I have a craving for that utilitarian Jersey pizza. It’s just heavenly, and these guys knocked it out of the park. No wonder they’ve been there for 60 years. If you're expecting anything fancy or modern, it ain't that. It's just seriously solid old school pies, made the way they should be, and I'm here for it. 65...

I have been going to Nicole's for many years and like many good things it's sad to say they have gone down hill. I ordered a slice of pizza and a sausage roll and me friend ordered a salad with chicken on it. After a long wait the salad with chicken came and my friend slowly ate their entire meal before my slice of pizza came. Had had to go up twice and ask what the hold up was. Meanwhile we where literally the only table in the whole place. The slice came dried out and burnt. The sausage roll was another 10 minutes so I said please wrap it to go and I paid and did not even take it. Before I wrote a review I decided to call the owner because I have been coming in on and off for 20 years. I was told by the person on the phone "I'm the owners son so that makes me the owner and you wee rude so I'm not going to talk to you. This is the first review I have ever felt compelled to write but wow terrible service, bad food and a jerk owner good luck...

I just had the most delicious meal from Nichola’s today. I got a cheesesteak with fried onions and mushrooms, six mild wings and an antipasto salad. I ordered delivery and the food came super fast and was unbelievably delicious! The cheesesteak was piping hot and the juice from the steak had seeped into the roll and made it so delicious! I also liked that there was no gristle in the meat. It was tender and delicious. The wings were very good and not chewy and I believe it was a homemade hot sauce they put with them. And the antipasto salad was amazing! Huge! and lots of delicious meats and cheeses and vegetables on it. I especially loved the mozzarella cheese – it had a very good flavor and I really enjoyed the salad. Plus they give you garlic bread with a salad and that was delicious as well. Overall the food was amazing and I will definitely be ordering from them on a...