Tuscany NY Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria — Restaurant in Lumberton

EXTREMELY disappointed with this place. Ordered a pizza.. was given a dry pizza with NO sauce, I paid $21 for a medium DRY pizza.. drove 20 min into town and 20 min back home. Called and they knew "something was missing" and yet handed me a pizza in place of saying hey we messed up and have to make another. Offered to deliver me sauce and not a pizza.. so i could dip a cold pizza in cold sauce?? Told them to credit me a pizza and I'll try them again another time.. just called today, and here I am leaving a crap review because now they only want to give me a partial credit on their screw up. That's poor business. It was my 1st and last time going here.. I'd rather trust teenagers to make my pizza at domino's than the adult that can't honor their word to a customer and admit a screw up. I really hoping to like this place but I'll spend my money with businesses that care what they give to...

We stopped when in town for the first time. Finally found this Italian place. Our food and service was outstanding, can’t wait to go back and try another dish. I had the Chicken Marsala with angle hair, delicious. My wife had the Chicken Contadina, she loved it as well. We shared the Mussels Marinara. The were very tasty as well. Our server was awesome, very attentive and willing to please. Can’t wait for our return, thanks everyone! One of the best meals we have had in Lumberton, we have stopped at least 20 times on the way back from Florida..

6/5/25 back again. Still 5 stars for food and service. Curran took care of us and provided excellent service. This time I had the pasta fagioli soup which was excellent. I also had the baked ziti and that too was awesome. My wife had a hogie which was very tasty. We will be back again to try some more...

My husband and I eat there at least once a week. We keep trying different things and have found every dish to be the best Italian we've had since they opened. We've lived and traveled this country for the past umpteen years (he's 91 and I'm 83) and this little hometown restaurant is by far the best. Not just the food but the people. They are so friendly. The restaurant has such a homey, laid back atmosphere. It is such a pleasant place to eat. (Now on Saturday night, it does get crowded and sometimes sounds like a big family...