Brothers Pizza — Restaurant in McSherrystown

This place is horrible. We wrote a review on here that actually got deleted because they probably didnt like what we had written, but it was the truth. I dont understand how these people are giving such high ratings, unless they are friends, but its very false. Their food is well below average and not made very well. Their hoagies were not what was expected whatsoever. Low quality meat put onto soggy buns and rock hard slices of pizza they expected us to pay well over 20 dollars for. Took the food back in once we opened it and realized the horrible quality to get an aggressive attitude from one of the employees. They said "What do you expect? This is the quality of our food here" and would only give back half the money in cash on untouched food. Do not recommend. There are definitely better places to get lower prices and...

Always great and quick service here! The staff is always friendly and attentive to the customer's needs. My family and I always enjoy dining here. The food is always great and I have never had any issues with any dishes. I have invited friends and family countless times and have enjoyed the speed and quality of service even with large groups. I frequently order take-out on my way home and the order is usually ready in less than 10 minutes. This is my go-to pizza place since it is quick, delicious, and conveniently...

My favorite pizza of all time is Pizzeria style Sicilian Base pizza. That's the way pizza was meant to taste Brothers Pizza has fresh ingredients and tastes so good Pizzeria style pizza. A little on the expensive side versus Little Caesars Domino's or Pizza Hut but for the ingredients and style of pizza you can't go wrong. Also there's Subs ones that we try are fabulous the bread is so soft and crispy on the outside thanks Brothers Pizza of...