Wise Guys Pizzeria — Restaurant in Merritt Island

Felt like pizza tonight and decided to take a chance and try out Wise Guys. I never try to order food in the last hour before closing, as a Chef, I understand that can be frustrating. I decided to keep it simple, so I ordered the largest cheese pizza they had.

First off, the customer service is great! The old man that owns it is personal with his customers and greets everyone that walks in while he’s making the pizzas.

The wait wasn’t long and they got it out at a decent time. No huffing about the time of night, no negative atmosphere, just old school pizza joint vibes.

Now the pizza. It was simple. Not too greasy, right ratio of cheese and sauce, crust was cooked perfectly. Overall just a stellar looking pie.

Delicious too. I highly recommend giving this place a try. If you’ve already tried it or you try it and it’s not your favorite or maybe you didn’t have a great experience, I urge you to try it at at least two more times to get something different. Maybe you just didn’t like what you ordered.

But go get some pizza...

Omg like oh my god oh man oh my gosh delicious delicious deliciousness outstanding astounding one of the best pizza ever and it is here in Merritt Island Florida we live like an hour and my aunt lives there so on 07/04/2025 my family 1st time which was the 4folks on Fri night and came with our aunt first for dinner the box of pizza pie half cheese half pepperoni and oh my god was astounding from crust to sauce oh man was the sauce astounding one of the best ever oh and from the service cheese and everything else we tried everything and all is amazing oh kind everyone is and desserts oh my gosh almond tortoni just like n.y. frozen oh man and keep on raving lol was so good me and my family came back here again for dinner on 07/05/2025 because was so excellent. Love the homey...

Stopped in for lunch and was greeted by the owners who are from NY. Good spirited and very attentive. Ordered two slices fresh out of the oven and a loaded small stromboli (big for a small). Slices were large, great thin crust, good under carriage, good tasting sauce and cheese ratio. I prefer slightly well done so I'd ask to keep in in two minutes longer on our next visit. The stromboli cooked to perfection and was loaded with pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage and mozzarella.

Appreciated the great NY Style food from back home as well as the good conversation with the owners. Would highly recommend this nice restaurant with great...