Azteca Bakery — Restaurant in Milwaukee

I definitely echo the other review saying this place is a hidden gem in Bay View. We get my sister's birthday cake from here every year because she only likes tres leches cake.

It's amazing, every time! Delicate whipped cream frosting covering a perfectly soaked cake with the perfect, milky flavor! I know eating a really moist cake like tres leches isn't everyone's jam, but it's ours!

Oh...and they are REALLY generous with their measurements. We ordered a 12 inch round and this baby was at least 16 inches and did not fit in the box lol.

I haven't had some of their more traditional/grab-and-go bakery items for years, but they were great the last time I had them and I'm SURE they still are!

NOT RECOMMEND *

Went to pick up my cake on Sunday October 10th and got the cake after I paid went to my truck and checked the cake it said a whole different name and different design I walk back in and say this isn’t my cake the guy who attended me was like ok and calls the other customer and was going back and forth with the costumer through the phone then expected me to take the cake to the other customer in order for me to get my cake I said no and when I get home i find out they did the same thing to my dad and were forcefully giving him a cake he didn’t order and...

I bought five different items to try. I bought three cake slices and two items I don’t know the names of. The lady who took care of me was very nice, they are well priced and they had an amazing selection, however, I tried four out of my five items and they were extremely dry. I’m very disappointed. I feel like with the vast amount of selection that they have they keep these items for a few days at a time. I was there around 6:30 PM and their cases were still mostly full. I might try them one more time just to see if it was an off day, but I wasn’t happy with what I...