Anika's Pizza — Restaurant in Moultonborough

7/22/2025: Brian reached out and made a very good point; "one bad experience should not wipe out years of good ones." I was hasty and not too big to admit my mistake. Thank you for making the effort!

7/22/2025: Thank you for you lengthy response but let's not get the facts clouded in words. Here is what you should take away:

I am a regular customer, with few exceptions, I order the same pie. This one was not like the previous 20+ I have ordered. Your employee just needed to acknowledge my pie was over cooked, rather than defend the obviously burnt crust.

The crust was charcoal and inedible, the same curst we have complemented you on previously.

You would rather I come to you? That's great, but you were not there. And speaking of how we would rather handle things; I would rather you say 'thank you for your feedback' and 'we hope you would give as another opportunity to earn your business" rather than try to tell a native New Yorker how New York style pizza is make.

7/20/2025: I have been going to this place since the opened and before when it was Artie's. They used to make a fantastic pizza but today they made me a burnt pizza and when i mentioned it she said this is how they always make it."

This was a new person, not the owners who I always who have always been there previously. And while she did offer to remake my pizza I would have rather she acknowledge...

Anika’s is rad! We just happened to be driving through town on our way to North Conway when we saw the sign in the distance and thought it might be a cool place, as we got closer we saw “plant-based options” and lost our minds! We had already eaten and they were closed but we were set on coming back, so we did the next day. While not exclusively vegan, almost everything on the menu can be made vegan. The pizza and calzones we had were phenomenal! Everything we ordered was great but the service was even better! We unknowingly showed up just a few minutes before closing but the owners(husband and wife) graciously offered to let us dine in. They were both so friendly and welcoming. As if that wasn’t awesome enough, the place is decked out in 80’s nostalgia that had me pointing out all kinds of childhood favs to my 5 year old. The Goonies will greet you at the door and Pac-Man, Michael Jackson, the super Mario bros, and even Pee-Wee Herman await you further inside! We’re from Ct so, unfortunately, we won’t be back often but will definitely be stopping by the next time we’re in New Hampshire.

I was too excited to dig in and forgot to take pics of our food but here’s a couple of...

I can give you multiple reasons why you should spend every cent you have at this establishment. It's newly owed and decorated, giving you the 80s-early 90s vibes you didn't know you needed. Other than the ambience that sends you back to the past, you are welcomed in, as if you are home, by some of the most genuine, friendly staff and owners you may ever find on the east coast. Now if all of that doesn't entice you enough....the food will. Now I'm 100% vegan and walked in asking about their plant based options they advertise and was pleasantly surprised that ANYTHING on their menu they will make vegan for you. Now, there are a rare few exceptions, but they are working on those being options too! So whether you're a summer rental or all season lifer, meat eater or full on Vegan, please, please, PLEASE, go support this local restaurant; there are options for everyone whether you want the real meat or vegan. Your best pizza, sub joint and good food eatery in the Winnipesaukee and Lee's Pond area. You absolutely won't be disappointed. I tried a vegan pizza myself and it is now in my top 5 of best vegan pizzas I have had in New England!...