Pucillo's Pizza and Subs — Restaurant in Myerstown

No doubt, this is the best pizza in Myerstown. I come from Philly, and I have had amazing pizza, wings and other fried food. This place is as close to home as I can find in the area. The pizza is spot on. The subs have a homemade bread, and it was probably the best meatball sandwich I have ever had.

The wings are good too, but I have one word of advice: DO NOT GET THE DRY RUB WINGS. This would have EASILY been a five-star review, if not for the dry rub wings. Maybe it was my batch, but I would not risk it again. I'm the kind of guy who adds salt to his already salted fries. I love salt, and add it to almost everything in amounts most people hate... but those dry rub wings... Whatever the salt version of diabetes is, I have it now. The hot wings were awesome, and I took a bite of the dry rub wings, and it was like they had deep fried them in salt, rolled them in old bay seasoning, rubbed in some more salt, and made sure the box and tin foil for carryout was salted also. The worst part was when they were recommended to me by the person who answered the phone. :/

Overall, we will definitely go back over and over again. If only they delivered. No one in Myerstown delivers! It is seriously the worst part of ordering pizza/chinese/ANYTHING in this town, is that NO...

Called to place an order at 6:30, I am aware they close at 7, I asked before placing the order if it was okay since it the shop was closing. I was told that is okay okay . I get there and everyone is very friendly and our pizza was still being made. We waited for the pizza to be done and when I got home the pizza wasn’t even cooked. I couldn’t pick up a slice without everything falling off of it. The fries were very cold and hard also. I understand they were closing soon, hence why I asked if it was even okay to place the order. I know everyone probably wanted to get home but the food wasn’t even edible…. We were very excited to try the food but unfortunately we won’t be...

First time and last time order. Mozzarella sticks hard as rocks. They looked as though they were fried twice. Marinara sauce was watered down. Fries were not fresh cut and were ice cold. Maybe because they were made before the 45 minute wait for a plain cheese pizza?! Turkey sub extremely dry with little turkey meat. Calzone had single slice of ham lunch meat and was flat as a pancake. Mozzarella cheese was included in the calzone sparingly and NO ricotta. Thought we'd try since it's local but honestly question how this place stays in business. Competition is 100 times better whether you stay in Myerstown or drive...