Panthers Pizza — Restaurant in Nappanee

Its a nice pizza parlor with very good food. The atmosphere resembles the traditional 80's/90's pizza parlor; they even have a video game from that era set to "freeplay" next to the front door. The pizzas themselves are substantial and very tasty. They also serve sandwiches, pastas, wings, and ice cream (either in a cone or pre-packaged pint), but I didn't order any of these things. They lose a star for this: It's expensive. 2 of their in-house, 18" specialty pizzas, 1 fountain drink & 3 waters cost $80. It's a little cramped for dine-in. They have lots of tables, and we were the only ones dining in that night. But, if they were busier, it would have been very difficult to move around. They have a keto crust but couldn't tell me anything about it. There are plenty of crusts that say "keto friendly", but arent really. When I asked them about that crust, they couldn't tell me how it was different from their other crusts. All-in-all, I'd go back... but only when I'm looking for something other than the traditional...

Ordered delivery.. arrived within an hour. One of the only places that delivers out here. It was nice to have that. Thank you for offering that as a service. The Pizza was hot. Delivery driver was nice. Ordering was easy. Can’t complain about that.

However, It’s on the pricier side. Around $30 for 1 pizza with delivery and it was pretty flavorless. I asked for a thin crust pepperoni and definitely did not receive that. The crust is very thick. Disappointed because I didn’t want regular thick crust pizza, and I wasn’t able to eat more than a piece. :/ There was at most 10 pieces of pepperoni on the large. Lacking sauce and cheese as well. (Looks like there is ton, but it’s just the thick crust making it look like that.)

Don’t know if I would ever try this place again. Will opt for little ceasers, papa john’s, pizza hut, dominos, ect. instead.

Edit: SOME of the pieces were thin crust. My apologies. About less than half was thin. Just seems it was not rolled...

Updated review: 5 stars moved to 1 and will NOT BE RETURNING! I ordered a small cheese pizza, extra cheese with a side of banana pepers. Total came to $22.54. The pizza was uneven and very little cheese, as seen in the pictures. Looked like a high school kid made it and didn't care! The peppers were put ON the pizza in a cup, so there was an indent of a cup on the pizza. Crust was hard, like homemade play dough that went dry. Used to be great but now the worst pizza ever.

Old review: Really good! I have been looking for decent pizza in the area and this place is probably my new "go-to" spot. Its smaller than I figured, and parking is hard to come by, but we'll be back.

Had a medium "Panther" pizza, mozzarella sticks and Panther bites and all was tasty. Filled us...