Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant — Restaurant in New York

When I arrived, I was told I had to order my food at the register before I sat down. I have never been at a restaurant where I was told to order, pay, and then sit. 😒 I had ordered Fettuccine Alfred with shrimp. There wasn't enough sauce, the noodles was under cooked, there was no flavor at all. I ordered lobster ravioli, which had no lobster. I had this dish before somewhere else. They should definitely take this dish off the menu or at least let someone know not to expect lobster. Then, as we were sitting down eating, a fly flew on the Fettuccine Alfred, told the waitress, the cook in the back told to waitress that it was seasoning, which that was a lie, even the waitress said it was definitely a fly. We got our money back on that one dish. I paid a total of $94 dollars on what, I don't know. I don't recommend this place to anyone. I will never come here again. I'm actually writing this as I'm sitting...

For me, I judge a pizza place on 2 criteria foods; their plain pizza and their Buffalo Chicken pizza. I usually order one of each but after seeing the Buffalo slice I had to stick with that one alone. Well seasoned chicken smothered on top of a light, crispy, thick, deep dish/Sicilian style crust. Mozzarella cheese on top, and in my opinion not nearly enough. No bleu cheese dressing on it either, much to my dismay.

With that said, I have to say I really had no complaints. A good amount of heat that almost brought me to a sweat but very much with the necessary flavor in the heat to make it worthwhile. Eating this monstrous 1 slice was hard; the chicken was piled high and wide, with pieces continually falling onto me. BIB REQUIRED! The overall volume of food was a challenge in and of itself.

If you find yourself in the area, I reccomend you come in and enjoy a slice of this. You won't be...

Second time our order was screwed up. First time we requested fresh mushrooms through their online web ordering service and paid extra and we got canned mushrooms. The second time we ordered sauce on the side for the calzone and it didn't come with it. We also ordered two burgers with cheddar that we had to pay $1.00 extra per burger. They called to say they didn't have cheddar but we didn't get our credit back for the more expensive cheese. When we called they told us they couldn't give us our money back but let them know the next time we order that we have a credit. They said he sauce was coming for our calzone but half an hour later when we called to ask where it was they said oh we are sending it now!!! They tried to blame their software for the problems and our solution was to get a new software program. Will not be ordering again...