Cafe Premiata — Restaurant in New York

I would give this place a 4.5 out of 5!

My wife and I went for our 6 month anniversary.

The ambiance and place was beautiful! So fun and lively! We ordered:

1. Porcini Arancini = It was absolutely delicious and flavorful! My favorite! Mushroom, risotto and truffle. The best Trio combination you can get!

2. Arugula and Baked Feta = Everything paired really well together! The feta went well with the pear. Never saw that going together but pleasantly surprised. Only thing I would say is the plating could be better. You can make it a lot nicer with the baked feta and pears than laying it on the side of the salad.

3. Shoshito Peppers = As my wife says every time I bring them up she says "Yummy". It was also a lot of fun. My wife hates spicy foods and I love spicy! We both would eat one and see who ate a spicy one.

Then we go to the main course!

4. Wild Halibut = When we got this dish, the halibut was tasty mouthwatering! When I cut into the fish you can see a beautiful and glistening white inside! However, I would have rested the peppers on top rather than have it hiding under the fish.

5. Wild Mushroom Pappardelle = Small serving size but tasteful! The plating of the pasta was very nice! I do feel there was something missing that can really bring out this dish to its potential. But they most certainly did not skip on the mushroom portions!!

6. We had to get there dessert special which was the cinnamon roll. WOW! I mean... WOW! It was Incredible! I tried stopping myself from eating it as I am on a diet, but we finished the whole thing. It was sweet and savory. The nuts on top are a great addition! WOW!

7. tiramisu cake = Was not a fan of it. I did not understand why they put Cherries on top of it. I also did not like how it was in a dish. The whip cream was dense and the cake itself was bitter. When we brought it to the managers attention he was very nice and was open to feedback.

The Waitresses there were so nice and always looking our way to see if we ever needed anything. They Recommended really good food as you can see! They were never rude and always polite!

Overall my wife an I had an amazing time at Cafe Premiata! We will most definitely be...

Amazing! Just went for the first time with my husband last night. I usually don’t post reviews but this one is worth the effort. Definitely was of the BEST dairy restaurants we’ve been to both in experience and in food. The menu was unique- not your run-of-the-mill dairy kosher food. The dessert- WOW! Made in-house, fresh- just wow. ORDER DESSERT! Other recommendations are the spicy honey pepperoni pizza which was amazing. The salad was so fresh with such good vegetables. You could really see the quality and freshness of the food really set this place apart from other restaurants. Also the music and vibe set it apart as well. The only negatives that I would mention were that it was a very busy Saturday night and service was slow, the Sangria needed more red wine, and the bread they serve with dinner was plain, not toasted and came with no condiments. Overall, food was AMAZING, vibes were amazing, and we are so happy that we finally have a restaurant of this caliber in Queens. Going to come bring my friends for my...

EXTRAORDINARY DINING EXPERIENCE ON EVERY LEVEL. This review is long overdue and well deserved. I've come for dinner with my family 4 times now and I'm IMPRESSED more and more. Anatoli and his team are true professionals operating this best kept secret of Kosher Restaurants from presentation to taste, service and the vibe they earned a TEN ! They get it and their extensive experience in the industry shines through. The Sushi / Sashimi is Magnificient. Best Thai Chili Whole Red Snapper, delicious butterfly whole Dorado, and the Pizza Pies put any pizzeria to shame. Attention to detail shines through in everything they do. This has quickly become my Go To dinner spot and My Happy Place for a predictable awesome dining experience every time. Make reservations or you might get turned away as this NEW HOT SPOT gets packed quickly and for good reason. Special Thanks to Luis, a very caring and personable server that makes your experience that much more memorable. Will be...