Prima Pizza — Restaurant in New York

2024 UPDATE

It appears Prima is under new management and the standards have sadly dropped. What used to be delicious pizza is no longer. Tried to call on a Saturday night to schedule a pickup of a regular pie. I ended up having to walk down to place my order. Was told 10 minutes but ended up having to wait 20. Pizza that was served was hot but crust is thin (Prima had thick delicious crust previously!) and told the man behind the counter the phone was off the hook and was given a rather confused look. This is our last visit of this pizzeria unfortunately.

OLD REVIEW BELOW*

This is our go-to spot. Great pizza, great garlic knots, and always tasty and fresh. We usually have a small wait but it’s okay especially when the food is good. Prices are reasonable and affordable, nothing like getting a pie, 6 knots, and a pinwheel for a total of $25 with drinks. Love having this...

Awful. Ordered a supreme pizza for pickup. When I arrived the "cook" gave me a pepperoni and sausage pizza. I returned it and asked for a supreme. He had NO IDEA what goes on it. I said mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives. 10 minutes later he says he's out of mushrooms. Then he says he's out of peppers. Why didn't he say that 10 minutes earlier? I asked for tomatoes then. When he finally finished, I could see the pepperoni and tomatoes weren't cooked and thrown on last. The cashier said the real cook didn't show up for work. Ok. If you don't have ANY cooks, you can't be open. The pizza is terrible and inedible. And my stomach hurts....

I called for pick up and ordered the Special combo #4 which is a Large Pie, 8 wings & soda. My wife went inside to get the food as i was waiting in the car with our 2 year old. First, the menu has it priced at $21.99 but when we arrived the owner said it was $25 (false advertisement). Second, the owner was very rude to other costumers and scolded his workers. Third, we waited over an HOUR for our pizza even though he said 20 minutes. And lastly the pizza was a Medium pie NOT large, the wings were cold and soda options was very limited. I felt like we got scammed with our food. Never going back. I would not...