Margherita's Pizza — Restaurant in Newark

Margherita’s Pizza is the definition of classic, no-nonsense pizza done right. A staple in Newark for years, this spot offers that nostalgic pizzeria feel with red-checkered tablecloths, handwritten specials on the wall, and the irresistible smell of fresh dough and garlic. It's a casual, counter-service place, great for grabbing a quick slice or sitting down with friends for a laid-back meal. I ordered a large Margherita pie—thin crust, fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, and basil. The crust was thin and crispy but still had a nice chew, and the tomato sauce tasted homemade with a touch of sweetness. The ingredients were fresh, and the balance of flavors was just right. I also sampled a slice of the buffalo chicken pizza, which packed a nice spicy kick and was loaded with cheese and tender chicken. They also offer subs, pasta dishes, calzones, and salads. Prices are more than fair, and portions are generous. Service was quick and friendly, and even though it was busy, the staff kept everything moving efficiently. It's not a gourmet or modern fusion pizza spot—it's old-school, reliable, and absolutely satisfying. If you’re looking for authentic East Coast-style pizza with no frills but full flavor, Margherita’s hits the...

Food is great, don't change anything in that respect. Service, I'm not used to being spoken to that way anymore, honestly. The attitude of the girl upfront when I didn't understand what she was saying and she wouldn't take the time to explain it was irritating. I'm hearing impaired. I'm younger and I don't look like it but I am. She was more interested in talking to the guys around and treated me like an interruption so I doubt informing her would have helped. Becoming defensive and throwing up an attitude is never the way to go. You're not good at business if this is the face of it. I paid, I tipped the poor kid that checked me out who looked very uncomfortable, and left without a scene. Figured this review would be enough. Food is great so unfortunately I will never give you...

I have loved this place for years, since it was a hole-in-the-wall storefront on Main street. It now has a nice, more spacious location.

The pizza is fantastic, I think the best traditional NY-style pizza in town. Fairly thin crust, but the edge is chewy. Toppings are always fresh. The sausage here is unusually good quality among pizza places.

I also like that they sell by the slice, great if you drop in by yourself and just want a snack or quick meal.

If I had a suggestion for an improvement it would be that there are a few too many blue-light bulbs in the seating area...I would love if these were replaced with less harsh, all warm lighting. Slightly dimmer lighting would be nice later in the evening too, the bright light is fine during the day but grates on me when it's...