Brooklyn Char — Restaurant in Noblesville

Noblesville Gets a Slice of the Big Apple at Brooklyn Char

Noblesville locals, rejoice! We finally have a phenomenal pizza spot, and it’s called Brooklyn . This isn't just good local pizza; this is the real deal—a truly authentic taste of New York style that Noblesville has been desperately needing.

The pizza itself is exactly what it should be. The crust is magnificent: perfectly cooked, crispy, and foldable, with that signature char and chew that defines the style. They don't skimp on the ingredients either; the pies come loaded with plenty of fresh, high-quality toppings. Every bite feels authentic, satisfying that specific craving for genuine East Coast flavor.

But you absolutely cannot leave without trying the extras. Do yourself a massive favor and grab the garlic knots. They are warm, buttery, flavorful, and truly yummy—the perfect sidekick to any pizza order.

A quick note for first-timers: while they do have some seating, Brooklyn Char is primarily an order and pickup place. It’s set up to deliver fast, fantastic takeout, so plan accordingly.

This is a must-try establishment. I will definitely be...

Update - 3.26.25

The owner reached out to me stating the issue was resolved and gifted me two free pizzas. I tried them again today and I am updating my review.

The cheese pizza was much better this time around. Awesome flavor and great crust.

The onion and mushroom pizza was my favorite. It was super delicious and the flavor was great!

Overall I am really happy with the owner taking responsibility and making things right. That is great costumer service! I’ll have a full updated review up on my YouTube channel coming soon! (Amazingislife on YouTube)

We got two pizzas. One Cheese and one Onion and Mushroom. The cheese was decent but the onion and mushroom was undercooked. The crust was still semi raw. Really disappointed as I was sooo excited to try this place.

I love NYC style pizza and having lived there for a year and a half had it a lot. This was did not live up to that at all.

Really nice people though and the customer service...

We dined in. Walked in and sat down…the counter to order is hidden around the corner and there isn’t signage (yet anyway) to tell you where to order. Walked up and figured it out after a few minutes. Ordered stuffed breadsticks and pizza ~$40.

Pizza was done and came out first. Was given very thin paper plates, which got grease-soaked pretty quickly. (Pizza+grease is a given) We don’t live local or we would just do carry-out.

Pizza is huuuuge! Can easily feed 4-6 people. Flavor was good; especially the sauce - definitely a good pizza that isn’t a “chain” - very heavy slices….couldn’t finish 2 slices. Box was so big it was hard to fit in the refrigerator- we will be eating this for a couple of days!

Not giving 5 stars for this visit; would do 4.5 if it was an option. May return if we needed to feed more than 2 people.

I Tre Mori has been our go-to in the area with a smaller pizza; there were some similarities in the sauce. Brooklyn Char worth a...