Nicolo's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Old Bridge

Nicolos has always been a childhood favorite of mine growing up, but even now as an adult, it is still so delicious! Their penne vodka is amazing & my picky toddler even loves it. Chicken parm subs are a hit & so is their house salad. Also, this is the only pizza place in town that can get the eggplant parm just right. I’ve tried it from a few other places and it was no good, as it was undercooked. Nicolos always cooks their eggplant perfectly. We also recently catered their meatballs and sautéed broccoli which was delicious. Their half trays for catering are exceptional & their prices are fair for both catering and regular food/takeout. Also, their pizza is one of the best (pepperoni is my fav)...

I moved to Old Bridge about a year ago, and Nicolo's has quickly become one of my local favorites! I can always count on the food being consistently delicious every time I order. Some of my favorites include their sesame chicken pizza, mussels, penne vodka, garlic bread / knots, chicken parm sandwich, wraps, and anything labeled "Sean's Favorite"—haha!

The customer service is always great, and orders are ready quickly (unless they’re super busy, which is a good sign because they’re that popular). Oh, and for a pizzeria, their salads are always so fresh! I’m definitely looking forward to trying more items...

I have to be honest , I have gotten very good pizza's in the past but recently I was shocked at what the pie looked like after I got home and opened the box. Hardly any cheese and the crust was so thin that the sauce leaked thru and the box was thicker than the pie itself. Never had this problem before , the owner needs to be there and not trust these kids he hires. They don't have the passion for making pies --- only passion they have is texting and talking on their cell phones. I will only go there when the owner is...