Humpty Dumpty Creek Side — Restaurant in Old Lycoming Township

I was impressed with the quality of the ingredients, the taste, and the presentation. We were in town and found the shop on maps. We went in to order. We ordered the Ribeye Cheesesteak and a Godfather sub. Both 8". The wait was around eight to ten minutes. The price was great. A little more than some other places, but this place does not skimp on ingredients. I have never had a sandwich that came with so much meat and cheese. The quality of the meats were excellent. The flavors were very good. The bread ( sub roll ) was also excellent. They toast them perfectly. The garden ingredients were fresh and flavorful as well. I will definitely return here next time...

We have ate here and ordered from here almost 1000 times over the years. Was always one of my favorite sub shops. Gets worse every time and this will be our last experience with them. This last time we ordered a cheesesteak... Came out with very little meat and about five pieces of lettuce. I ordered a dirty politician... Was only one that came out ok. Husband ordered roast beef Cosmo sub... Came out on toasted hot dog rolls ( he was not happy) also the staff was all young kids who obviously can't make subs. Very rude, loud, and cursing while my toddler was sitting there....

Door was a little funky lol other than that we walked in and the girl was multi tasking our pickup order and someone else calling so they definitely aren't slacking. Atmosphere felt like I was in someone else's house when I was in there great smell was a little smal due to the counter but there is space to sit and eat or sit while you wait. Alot of the people working are nice and are cooperative. These people have alot of orders toward the end of the day/dinner time so if your order takes long dont be rude like I've seen on...